4 ms·
$16,000,000 spent to acquire users that you had to then build a "block all other users" feature for. Does anyone know how successful this was at getting people
by jrockway 7y ago
$16,000,000 spent to acquire users that you had to then build a "block all other users" feature for.
Does anyone know how successful this was at getting people on to the platform? I had the same number of friends on Keybase before the airdrop was announced as I do now.
- duelingjello 7y agoYeah, giving away money scales only in the short-term like a negative price product, increasing demand that usually doesn't translate into recurring users or revenue. I think they need more freemium and related paid services, and integrations. Like why aren't they also the "gravatar" of GPG fingerprints and keys? They also need a widget generator to spread the word on websites.
- Boulth 7y agoHow would a "gravatar of GPG fingerprints and keys" look like?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sneak 7y agoThe money was spent by Stellar, who raised a huge amount during the ICO hype era, and have been quietly spending it in huge chunks in an attempt to build a market for their shitcoin from scratch. Their CAC must be 10x that of almost any other internet business, but, hey, they can afford it. They supply the tokens, and presumably are paying Keybase for access to their userbase (and non-removable ads for their coin on almost every single keybase profile page). https://github.com/keybase/client/issues/15555 https://github.com/keybase/client/issues/15555
- jrockway 7y agoI just don't understand how it's a good investment. For the people that desperately needed the free $20, they probably immediately withdrew it and will not be building any blockchain apps in the near future. So what did Stellar even get? A few crazy people that use a very off-the-beaten-path chat app now know about it? I feel like the money could be better spent. I also don't see how this works as a pump-and-dump to turn their ICO into actual United States Dollars. With the vast majority of people wanting hard currency instead of a cryptocoin... I feel like that can only drive the price down. Looking at some charts (https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/XLM-USD/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/XLM-USD/), XLM has been trending downward for a year. There is a small spike right around the time of the first airdrop. Maybe that was all they needed to make some money? I don't really know but it all seems shady to me. I have decided not to hold this against Keybase; it's an experimental app for "stuff" that I don't have to pay for. I am still suspicious of cryptocurrency in general, and especially ones I haven't heard of like Stellar.
- sneak 7y agoStellar couldn't sell those coins for face value today without tanking the price and thus value proposition of their platform. The airdrop is for a significant chunk of their token's daily non-wash volume, and would trigger a lot of price instability if they tried to cash it out themselves. I truly think they are simply okay with a $200-500+ CAC because it's all found money anyway (that dumping on an exchange would ultimately disclose and hurt future potential profits). If they can make it actually get adopted, they stand to make a lot more—but it's a huge if.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoYou are thinking about this wrong. This is not money they had and are now losing but value that they created and are now distributing to improve the robustness of their economy (everybody wins). The SDF actually burned a lot of tokens recently (way more than this airdrop) as well because they concluded they were stockpiling too much and thus were putting their economy at risk. the point of this airdrop was to increase circulation of XLM among real users. The reason they are stopping it is that keybase had to scramble to keep bots, spammers, etc. out, which kind of defeats the purpose because you get a few bad actors accumulating disproportionately large amounts of tokens. I was on Stellar already and received both airdrops so far. About 55$ in total at the current rate. It peaked out at ~65$ a few weeks ago. It's a nice gesture; much appreciated. I already earned (as in I worked for it) some XLM through other means so I have a nice stash that I'm HODLing. Keybase is actually a nice product. It lacks a few of the niceties of Slack but it has made nice progress over the last year. Setting up a team is quite easy and right now they are not really charging for it. I would consider it for a small team.
- jrockway 7y agoYeah, I like the product and I think sending money in a chat app is nice. I guess it doesn't really affect me that the userbase is 50% crypto speculators. I don't have to interact with them.