4 ms·
We've had innumerable discussions about the practical impossibility of what various Governments are asking for in relation to encryption. Those who know... know
by BLKNSLVR 7y ago
We've had innumerable discussions about the practical impossibility of what various Governments are asking for in relation to encryption. Those who know... know. There's no more debate needed, the mathematics speaks for itself, the history of security breaches speaks for itself (and is only ever gaining in its volume of evidence).
The technology industry needs a template reply referring to the obvious examples of the two pillars, mathematics and history of security breaches, to dismissively reply to any further such requests now and anytime in the future. We shouldn't need to get caught up in any of their cleverly constructed strawman arguments and appeals to emotion. Those who keep bringing these topics up are essentially performing a DoS on the technology industry by tying up resources having to argue established fundamental truths and logic over and over.
So, why do we have to keep spinning our tyres on this?
1. Control: The well established push towards surveillance and the police state that protects the status quo. Technology has accelerated the enablement of this.
2. Power: The powers-that-be don't like being told by 'nerds and geeks' what is and is not possible, despite the very same 'nerds and geeks' creating the technology that has enabled the acceleration of Control. The technology industry's continued non-compliance undermines their desired image of Power.
But, because this whole argument is so purely a power play it's not likely to stop (without fundamental changes to the fabric of society at least). As such, a template reply is needed to mitigate this DoS
- nl 7y agoThis comment is wrong on so many levels. It is absolutely technically possible to provided communications with the ability for a government to read them. No one debates that. Many claim that the security and privacy trade off in doing that is not worthwhile. The technology industry needs a template reply referring to the obvious examples of the two pillars, mathematics and history of security breaches, to dismissively reply to any further such requests now and anytime in the future. We shouldn't need to get caught up in any of their cleverly constructed strawman arguments and appeals to emotion. This is absolutely the wrong response. This is a political argument, and the correct response is in the field of politics, not a glib template argument that appeals to technologists view on security trade-offs.
- Nasrudith 7y agoPolitical arguements is a fool's game as they are experienced manipulators after power. Sociopaths in other words. Not playing the expert's games is the only way to win against them. Force them to insist upon what every expert says is impossible. The only "answer" they can have to that are more spin spun bullshit or making it their own. A "don't use me ever" form of encryption if they actually succeeded (any other option is better) or they create a tower of babel standing on a vertical gnat's hair - an inevitable collapse on any foolish enough to use it that only damages the arrogant fool who made it further.
- nl 7y agoForce them to insist upon what every expert says is impossible. What does "impossible" mean here? It is certainly possible to build an encrypted messaging system that doesn't use end-to-end encryption and that allows someone within the company that runs that system to read the messages. There are plenty of existing messaging systems that work this way, even today (eg, FB Messenger in non-private mode, Slack, plenty of video products). Plenty of them have a long history of operating without having unauthorised information leaked. So again - what is impossible? I agree entirely that E2E encryption is much better, but we are fooling ourselves to say anything else is impossible. Political arguements is a fool's game as they are experienced manipulators after power. Sociopaths in other words. Not playing the expert's games is the only way to win against them. I'm not entirely convinced by this argument. I think that banning E2E is primarily pushed by security agencies, and I think politicians don't particularly care about this topic at all.