4 ms·
I have no experience with what this guy is talking about. Maybe "They" are tracking me just as assiduously as him, and desperately trying to get their ads proj
by ncmncm 7y ago
I have no experience with what this guy is talking about.
Maybe "They" are tracking me just as assiduously as him, and desperately trying to get their ads projected onto my retinas, but I never see any online ads at all. Hence, I never see targeted ads.
If I were ever to turn off UMatrix, I probably would be shocked. But why would I do that?
So my main complaint about The Web These Days is that everything works badly, when it works at all. Amazon search can never bring up what I want to buy, even when I know it exactly. Ebay, likewise. Google cannot find anything that might be vaguely connected to a Product they would rather I were searching for instead.
Google Maps was going all to hell until recently, but appears to have recovered, some, and arrested the slide.
- gumby 7y agosoothing tone oh, just enable that sweet tracking and we'll know enough to give you exactly what you're looking for. Poor you, you didn't realize you were making it impossible to help you. /soothing tone I only read part of the article but as far as I got the author seemed to feel he would not be able to resist the blandishments of the advertiser/spies.
- Ill_ban_myself 7y agoThere's one big difference here, I'd bet. Do you have children? Or a spouse? Because as assiduously as you can corral your own content for pesky ads there will be devices, services, and platforms that your children or your spouse use that will leak into your life. The day your child asks you why youtube keeps giving him ads for diabetes medication and you have to face your still unresolved feelings about your mother's death and explain that he'll probably one day have to have daily injections and a few toes amputated and maybe deal with kidney failure is the day you'll probably feel the same as the author of this article.
- satyrnein 7y agoI pay YouTube not so I don't see ads, but so my kids don't see ads.
- Ill_ban_myself 7y agoFamily requires compromise and, like diplomacy, cannot effectively function with unlimited transparency.
- Cougher 7y agoI don't think a hyperbolic unlikelihood is a good argument that the poster will feel like the blogger one day.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoOuch! Thanks for the very vivid argument.
- prawn 7y agoI thought the problem with Amazon wasn't the search, but that you couldn't always trust it to deliver a legitimate brand product?
- bluebit 7y agoSeriously? Amazon has more filters and categories than I know what to do with, it would be very hard not to find exactly what you're looking for. How would you improve the experience?
- astura 7y agoAmazon has hundreds of pages of low quality and white label goods clogging up the searches.
- ncmncm 7y agoActually show me a single instance of the thing I asked for. It doesn't matter how many filter buttons they provide if no products that even vaguely match show up. Used to be there was a list of "people who looked for that bought one of these things", but that is gone.
- mcv 7y agoWhat surprises me is that for all their tracking, Google is surprisingly bad at telling what I'm interested in. They keep suggesting me Youtube videos about Minecraft, and it wouldn't surprise me if they showed my son Stephen Colbert and Trevor Noah, despite the fact that we use individual accounts. Their ads are just noise; rarely relevant to what I'm interested in.
- notduncansmith 7y agoGoogle is not in the business of satisfying your content needs, though: they are in the business of making money by getting people to look at screens. This may occasionally overlap with giving you what you’re looking for, but is by no means strictly linked.
- mcv 7y agoI was under the impression that they were in the business of targeted advertising. They want to know everything I do specifically to understand which ads are most effective to show to me. And effective here means: most likely to get me to click on them and buy something. So yes, showing me stuff I'm interested in should be pretty important to me. Knowing the difference between me and my son too. You can't effectively target ads if you're confused about who you're dealing with.
- notduncansmith 7y agoIt’s entirely possible that they make most of their money off of the top few percent of online spenders, who probably don’t need to be targeted that well to make most of the money that’s made online, hence not justifying an especially-honed targeting system. Plus, we’re in the beginning of the era where the data has far more lucrative and powerful uses than direct ad-matching, so again it may not be to their profit to invest heavily in that area. I don’t know Google’s economics obviously, but that’s my guess.