2 ms·
One infinity is not necessarily equal to another. You are correct. Equality is not a very useful concept for infinities, really, you need other concepts like on
by jerf 16y ago
One infinity is not necessarily equal to another. You are correct. Equality is not a very useful concept for infinities, really, you need other concepts like one-to-one mappings. Take one away from your infinity and you haven't done anything to its cardinality. A one-to-one mapping between the old infinity and the new one is still trivially available.
Words are useless. English is absolutely incapable of dealing with infinities in math, full stop. If you are arguing with English words, you're already wrong. That is why I said that I am presenting one useful way to think of them, and it is absolutely not the best or only way. What I showed was just a somewhat intuitive way to think of the infinity most commonly encountered in otherwise-conventional math and isn't totally correct there, either, it's just intuitively closer. Arguing about my intuitive shortcut misses the point entirely. You must go learn the math. I can't use the math terms to explain it to you here, either, because the correct understanding of the terminology would be tautological to understanding my point.
Also, I am not trying to be mean here. It took mathematicians decades to work out consistent definitions of infinity, and if you are going to insist on banging on the definitions and exposing the inconsistencies, an admirable enterprise, the only definitions that will stand up to that scrutiny are the ones that have been honed over the decades, and they do not fit well into HN posts. (Even if they are posted, they are thoroughly based on other mathematics that they would be meaningless until you understand those other things.) There's no Royal Road to infinity.
- giberson 16y agoVery good points. Obviously, math is a language in itself and trying to make arguments from the trappings of an inexact translation to another language like English is folly. >I am not trying to be mean here No worries, no maliciousness interpreted. Thanks,