3 ms·
If the amendment process is flexible enough to allow for throwing out the entire constitution and writing a new one, I feel like a more practical way to achieve
by kelnos 7y ago
If the amendment process is flexible enough to allow for throwing out the entire constitution and writing a new one, I feel like a more practical way to achieve drastic change would be to 1) write a new, idealized constitution, 2) diff it against the current one, 3) bucket the changes, 4) propose and ratify a series of amendments that gradually morph the constitution into what's desired.
Now, I don't expect that to happen either, but it seems more plausible. While it might be incredibly satisfying to throw everything out and start over, I'm not sure that's even wise, even ignoring the practical considerations.
Regardless, I think there's a lot of good in there that has held up really well over time, and we shouldn't be so quick to think we can do better. Some things have to go (like the overly-broad interstate commerce clause), and some things need to be added (like stronger rights to privacy), but I think we still have a solid base to work with.
Regardless^2, I don't even see the Equal Rights Amendment getting ratified (even ignoring its currently-expired state); anything larger seems too daunting. Our political client isn't amenable to any kind of constitutional amendments, and I expect that to be the case for many decades to come.
Regardless^3, the political machine seems to -- correctly -- believe that stacking the supreme court is the way to effect constitutional change nowadays, and they're unfortunately doing a good job of it so far.