4 ms·
I want a law that would make Facebook liable for the actions of their staff. The goal of such a law would push the company to implement measures to make individ
by onion2k 7y ago
I want a law that would make Facebook liable for the actions of their staff. The goal of such a law would push the company to implement measures to make individual bad actors have very little power to do bad things. In this case, simply having a requirement that several independent people (maybe in different offices) review a case before unbanning an account wouldn't be completely unreasonable.
- mliker 7y agoThat law would need to be applicable to all companies - Walmart, Target, Visa, etc.
- wcip 7y agoSeems like repealing section 203 in connection to paid advertisement would be sufficient, if Facebook publishes a advertisement that defrauds users and profits from it they can also share a portion of the blame.
- sharkjacobs 7y agothis law is sounding better and better
- naniwaduni 7y agoSome would call that a feature, not a bug. (Yes, yes, it'd be hard to pass, but)
- harrisonjackson 7y agoIt seems like every couple of weeks we see a founder or professional locked out of their accounts on some platform they depend on to make a living. Until that problem is solved I don't think we want to make it harder than it is to unban someone. Likely the bad actors would still find a way around it, too. What's a little criminal collusion amongst coworkers for profit.
- olliej 7y agoI mean there’s a real problem in that many people are arranging their livelihoods around single platforms. As much as I hate crowder for example, he ensured that most of his income comes from advertising his own store and products, so being demonetized for repeatedly violating YT policies didn’t actually cost him much.
- r00fus 7y agoie, fraud shouldn't be protected with the corporate veil. What if this wasn't an isolated incident and only one that got caught? What if the person who took the bribes was part of a ring? Corporations have a strong incentive to NOT root that out as it has negative image.
- perl4ever 7y ago"ie, fraud shouldn't be protected with the corporate veil." Isn't this the opposite of the corporate veil? The corporation is not being treated as a person, and the actual person is being held responsible.
- r00fus 7y agoThis isn't anything but the company firing someone for their own reasons. The issue at hand is a) us knowing that fraud was perpetrated and b) appropriate jurisdictions being able to try that individual for fraudulent actions. Neither is present today. Facebook polices its own employees and if those employees were important enough you'd bet they would not release that information nor hold those employees accountable.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe corporation itself is avoiding any culpability or liability for the offence, enacted by its staff, on its systems, through its capabilities, in its name. And to its (partial) benefit. By virtue of its own failed or abesent oversight and detection mechanisms.
- perl4ever 7y agoThe phrase "corporate veil" is a metaphor describing how someone or something is getting away with something by hiding behind the corporation they are part of. Like, the corporation is acting as a veil, over whoever is responsible. So, you're describing the opposite...right?
- dredmorbius 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- olliej 7y agoI’d want that extended to include joint responsibility of the highest level employees who were aware of criminal acts or fraud. After all the common refrain justifying huge incomes for high level employees/execs/board members is the “risk” in their jobs. That risk should include personal responsibility. As long as the only people who suffer meaningfully are normal ICs, customers, and small shareholders there’s no actual reason for the boards to change behavior. Fines are passed on as increased costs (PG&E), reduced wages (every company), etc - I’m sure once individual executives can be sent to jail for allowing criminal acts the behaviour will change. (Until they buy a law to remove their liability)
- sa46 7y ago> simply having a requirement that several independent people You're asking for government mandated bureaucracy. Here's how I've seen this play out in the context of the world's largest bureaucracy, the Department of Defense. Let's say the law requires someone in a powerful position, like a VP, to approve the un-ban request so you can hold someone "accountable". The following chain of events will occur: 1. The VP will be inundated with un-ban requests and become increasingly annoyed at requests that should obviously remain in effect. 2. The VP will delegate a subordinate to check that each request is sufficiently nuanced to require the full attention of the VP. 3. Repeat steps 1 and 2 until you reach a management level that's too over-burdened to add another review layer. You should have 2-4 layers of review at this point. To properly route a request, each layer queues the request and runs some cheap processing and sends it up the chain where the process repeats. We can borrow some concepts from networking to model this process: - buffer bloat: queues are typically unbounded in the real world. Requests are rarely dropped. Instead they accumulate. - back pressure: the VP goes on vacation. All requests will pile up at the previous layer. - latency: certain days have exceptionally high latency, notably Saturday, Sunday, and most parts of Friday. - network partitions: often the transport layer (usually an intern to shuffle paperwork) will become unavailable as the scheduler (boss) repurposes the intern to higher priority tasks. With a bit of tuning, a well-established bureaucracy can increase latency from minutes to months per request.