3 ms·
I think the worse news is the transcoding proxies they are announcing, not-so-transparently lowering the quality of any JPEG and MPEG files you download. This
by modeless 16y ago
I think the worse news is the transcoding proxies they are announcing, not-so-transparently lowering the quality of any JPEG and MPEG files you download. This is why the Internet needs end-to-end encryption on by default.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoMy weekend project is setting up OpenVPN on my desktop computer. Android and/or CM supports VPN.
- eli 16y agoI've always been curious with these transcoders and copyright law. Why are they allowed to alter and redistribute content without the permission of the author? Could I set up proxy that strips flash ads out of other people's content and replaces them with my own tasteful text ads? How is that different from scraping their content and reposting it on my server?
- patrickgzill 16y agoIf it is just transcoding then a) they are not storing it permanently, it is just in a "buffer" b) they are not changing the content any more than converting 16bit PCM audio to 8Khz voice quality (for instance for a music on hold application) is. That is, it is not "alteration" in that the song or image is still recognizably the same - they are not changing the rhythm of the song or the height of the buildings in the image.
- eli 16y agoIf copyright only protects content that is stored permanently, doesn't that mean I can stream whatever I want without paying for it?
- ars 16y agoFor copyright to take effect the work must be "fixed" in a tangible form. See here: http://www.bitlaw.com/copyright/obtaining.html#fixation http://www.bitlaw.com/copyright/obtaining.html#fixation That leads to a question of whether storing it in RAM counts as "fixed". I can't find a reference right now, but I remember reading that congress recently clarified the issue that storing in RAM does not count as fixed (and prior to that it was either an open question, or it did count).
- eli 16y agoSeems like it's got to be a lot fuzzier than that. So if Verizon replaced all banner ads on all sites you visit while using their network with their own ads, that would be legal? And I could create a website that appears to republish all the content from NY Times without ads so long as in the background I'm proxying requests back to their server and storing the results in RAM? Edit: I found a piece on the legality of web scraping in general http://www.galvanilegal.com/is-web-scraping-legal/ http://www.galvanilegal.com/is-web-scraping-legal/
- ars 16y agoComputer programmers are used to exact rules, but copyright law has a large subjective component, and it depends on what you do with it. So the exact same technical action can have varied legality depending on what the end user does with it and the intent of the person doing it. So striping ads in order to save bandwidth may be legal while stripping ads because you protest the concept of ads may not be. Or stripping ads (in order to save bandwidth) may be legal for your ISP but illegal for a 3rd party.
- tyhjnmyh 16y agoIn the UK British Telecom set up an ad service called Phorn that monitored your browsing and replaced ads with targeted ones from it's own suppliers. A huge public backlash when it replaced charity "save the children" ads with ones inviting you to buy interesting videos of schoolgirls, caused it reconsider what had only been 'a trial concept' The courts decided it had broken just about all the privacy/wiretapping laws but nothing to do with copyright. Naturally it got off with a warning under the 'laws don't really apply to big telecoms companies" amendment.
- kinofcain 16y agoAgreed, SSL should be the default.