3 ms·
I'm wondering why Saudi Arabia doesn't just buy the S&P 500 like any index fund. It doesn't seem that hard to diversify? Is it not possible at their scale? Nor
by skybrian 7y ago
I'm wondering why Saudi Arabia doesn't just buy the S&P 500 like any index fund. It doesn't seem that hard to diversify? Is it not possible at their scale?
Norway has a trillion dollar sovereign investment fund and they seem to be profitable and uncontroversial?
- wmil 7y agoThat doesn't generate any consulting fees for their friends.
- Cyph0n 7y ago> Norway has a trillion dollar sovereign investment fund and they seem to be profitable and uncontroversial? You're comparing apples to oranges. One is a sovereign wealth fund managed by citizens, for citizens. The other is a wealth fund managed by royalty, for royalty, with the main goal being to keep said royalty in power.
- smabie 7y agoAre you implying that royalty likes to lose money? Morever, thr Sauds run a massive welfare state, so it’s a little unfair to claim that Norway’s and Saudi Arabia’s funds are so different.
- Cyph0n 7y agoNot at all. Firstly, the royal family could care less about the welfare of the average Saudi citizen. Secondly, the royal family has full control over the fund (with zero accountability). Given these two facts, there is much less harm if they play hard and fast with the fund. Besides, most of the royal family already has their welfare guaranteed for life in the form of personal investments and the monthly salary.
- solveit 7y ago> Firstly, the royal family could care less about the welfare of the average Saudi citizen. This is ludicrous. Every regime cares about public opinion no matter how despotic.
- Cyph0n 7y agoI guess you should read up more on the current Saudi regime.
- smabie 7y agoDo you mean “couldn’t care less”?
- dv_dt 7y agoI'm no expert, but from what I imply from general coverage I've seen is that a lot of the cashflow is spoken for in operating Saudi gov't, public basic-income like payments, and family / ruling class payments. Again my guess, but making the case you need to cleanup the company finances for external investors and public accounting purposes may have been easier than trying to separate it out outright internally - either for the purpose of better long term diversification or, maybe, for the more cynical interpretation of gaining more family control of the asset of Aramco. Norway was pretty unique in that early on they decided to route most of the cashflow into their fund. They're an (the only?) exception to what has been called the resource curse. Oil riches usually don't work out as well as in Norway.
- bduerst 7y agoEven dropping $0.1 trillion into the $25 trillion SP500 fund would affect the price and cause inflation. Index funds do not have the capacity to absorb that much wealth, so large funds like the one in Norway seek out other investments just like Vision Fund.
- anm89 7y agoI don't get this part either. Imagine if they'd just thrown that money into AAA international real estate(ie buy skyscrapers outright in 20 major cities) or just run it like a private equity hedge and just bought major stakes in 20 world companies. It seems hard to imagine that those strategies wouldnt have done alot to diversify and future proof their wealth without gambling on something like wework. Maybe these transactions would be blocked under some type of foreign influence laws but maybe they could have also snuck under the radar by laundering credibility and origins through the vision fund.
- smabie 7y agoNorway doesn’t sink 1 trillion into the S&P 500. And why should Saudi Arabia to that? It’s a terrible idea. 100% exposure to US equities is a bad bad idea. Ideally as an investor, you wsnt to build a portfolio of uncorrelated assets.