5 ms·
On the contrary, Article V clearly states that it would require legislation on the part of two-thirds of the States, or passage by two-thirds of the House and S
by samatman 7y ago
On the contrary, Article V clearly states that it would require legislation on the part of two-thirds of the States, or passage by two-thirds of the House and Senate, and subsequent ratification by three-quarters of the state legislatures.
This would convene a Constitutional Convention, which in turn could rapidly pass an Amendment rendering the existing Constitution null and void upon ratification, after which they could turn their attention to creating and ratifying a new Constitution.
Not only would this be perfectly legal, I consider it an excellent idea.
- jaywalk 7y agoColor me embarrassed. Thanks for pointing this out.
- CamperBob2 7y agoThe effect would be the same. We would end up with a country of, by, and for the red states, for better or worse. It would be much better to focus on enforcing the existing Constitution, than to write a new one that would also end up being ignored when it proves the least bit inconvenient to the government. The world is full of "democratic" countries with lofty-sounding constitutions.
- javagram 7y ago3/4 of the states are not “red states”. Look at the composition of the Senate. Each state gets 2 senators, but there are only 53 republican senators, not 74-76 as one would expect if 3/4 states were solid red. In reality the country is divided enough that no wholesale rewriting of the constitution would ever be possible in the current political climate either way, using the amendment mechanism. Hence the importance of using the SCOTUS to reinterpret it one way or another instead...
- CamperBob2 7y ago3/4 of the states are not “red states”. Look at the composition of the Senate. Each state gets 2 senators, but there are only 53 republican senators, not 74-76 as one would expect if 3/4 states were solid red. I strongly disagree with your definition of "red states," given the electoral-vote map from the last Presidential election. In any case, my point is that rewriting the Constitution would have no beneficial effect anyway, because we'd just continue to ignore it.
- iamnothere 7y agoThere are organized movements to make this happen, such as https://conventionofstates.com/ https://conventionofstates.com/. Personally I am concerned that such a convention would lead to major changes (in the wrong direction) on individual rights and issues like privacy, censorship, and accountability for the powerful. On the other hand the original constitution is slowly becoming unworkable due to years of contradictory case law. "A republic, if you can keep it." Wise words.
- justin66 7y ago> Not only would this be perfectly legal, I consider it an excellent idea. An excellent idea in the abstract sense of hey, that's a really clever way to update the constitution, or an excellent idea in the sense of the politicians operating in America today can be trusted to update the constitution properly so let's do that? Only one of those isn't totally crazy...
- Spellman 7y agoAnd not only the politicians, but every lobbyist and lawyer and judge in the land would want a crack at changing things to their vision of a better Constitution. A Constitutional Convention is basically opening up one heck of a can of worms. Because remember, a Constitutional Convention gets full power to try and rewrite almost ANYTHING.
- samatman 7y agoIn neither sense, because a popular movement to replace the Constitution could only succeed by replacing the existing legislature with one which is amenable to such a course of action. It's far-fetched, I readily concede that. But it has a lot to recommend it, the very act of proposing and bringing to reality a Constitutional Convention would be a powerful engine of change, with a better-than-even chance we'd end up with a better system than we have now.
- jeffdavis 7y ago"a Constitutional Convention would be a powerful engine of change, with a better-than-even chance we'd end up with a better system than we have now" What makes you think that? I would put the odds of a better system at approximately zero. We had a rare, special moment in history that created our Constitution. The Bill of Rights is amazing and radical even today.
- anchpop 7y agoThis would actually not work exactly as stated, since there are several parts of the constitution that cannot be amended (every state being entitled to equal representation in the senate, for example). But most of those problems could be worked around
- int_19h 7y agoWhat makes you believe that this part of the constitution cannot be amended? Article V only says that it requires consent of the affected states - which would be all of them, so it's a high bar, but it's not outright prohibited.
- anchpop 7y agoOh, you're right, I misremembered. Is it the case that the bit about requiring the consent of all 50 states can be amended?
- int_19h 7y agoThat is a very interesting question. One could argue that the spirit of the clause necessarily implies that it cannot be amended itself without consent of all states. Another possibility would be to nullify the powers of the Senate. So all states would still be entitled to an equal representation, but it's in a body that is purely decorative, so they're welcome to it. This is also arguably counter to the spirit of that clause - although that would be more difficult to argue, since the power of all states would be equally diminished... But either were to actually happen, the question would rather be, to whom would you make that argument, and what power would they have to enforce such a decision anyway? I would dare say that if anybody got the supermajority necessary to amend anything, they could just roll with it and disregard any objections - just as they disregarded all those who considered the Constitution illegitimate, on the basis that its ratification didn't follow the requirements set by the Articles of Confederation.
- kelnos 7y agoIf the amendment process is flexible enough to allow for throwing out the entire constitution and writing a new one, I feel like a more practical way to achieve drastic change would be to 1) write a new, idealized constitution, 2) diff it against the current one, 3) bucket the changes, 4) propose and ratify a series of amendments that gradually morph the constitution into what's desired. Now, I don't expect that to happen either, but it seems more plausible. While it might be incredibly satisfying to throw everything out and start over, I'm not sure that's even wise, even ignoring the practical considerations. Regardless, I think there's a lot of good in there that has held up really well over time, and we shouldn't be so quick to think we can do better. Some things have to go (like the overly-broad interstate commerce clause), and some things need to be added (like stronger rights to privacy), but I think we still have a solid base to work with. Regardless^2, I don't even see the Equal Rights Amendment getting ratified (even ignoring its currently-expired state); anything larger seems too daunting. Our political client isn't amenable to any kind of constitutional amendments, and I expect that to be the case for many decades to come. Regardless^3, the political machine seems to -- correctly -- believe that stacking the supreme court is the way to effect constitutional change nowadays, and they're unfortunately doing a good job of it so far.