3 ms·
> you can say “sorry it didn’t work out” and then buy them out at a lower valuation with the money you have left over from not growing your business crazily. D
by paulddraper 7y ago
> you can say “sorry it didn’t work out” and then buy them out at a lower valuation with the money you have left over from not growing your business crazily.
Does SoftBank not have liquidation preferences???
This is the exact sort of thing that liquidation preferences prevent: buybacks at a lower value with the investor's own money.
Because otherwise, yes, you can indeed unscrupulously print capital.
EDIT: I suspect the author is either ignorant or grossly overstating the point.
- mschuster91 7y ago> EDIT: I suspect the author is either ignorant or grossly overstating the point Or SoftBank has a massive lack of core competency combined with being lucky enough to have hit the Saudi oil money well while drilling... imagine an alternate reality where Uber and WeWork have worked out, people would have hailed SoftBank as revolutionary visionaries.
- paulddraper 7y agoVisionary for not having liquidation preferences? That's like saying "visionary for not doing due diligence".
- jjeaff 7y agoLiquidation preference would not come into play unless you are selling off the whole company. The author says that the value of the shares was not public, but one would assume they did not get back nearly what they put in. Did you read the article before calling the author incompetent?
- paulddraper 7y ago> Liquidation preference would not come into play unless you are selling off the whole company. The wholesale liquidation would presumably provide a floor to the partial liquidation value. That's not necessarily true, but probably is. ("Overstatement")
- blackearl 7y agoAlso on HN front page is SB selling Wag stake back to...Wag
- twic 7y agoLiquidation preference held by A over B can't possibly be relevant to a stock transaction between A and B, because if A is happy to pay that price for the stock, they are also happy to waive the preference to do it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 0xffff2 7y agoConsidering "the author" is Matt Levine, who is not exactly an unknown, I think ignorant is off the table. Slightly overstating the point for comedic effect certainly fits within the theme of the newsletter though.
- smabie 7y agoPretty sure Matt Levine knows more than you about liquidation preferences.