7 ms·
Wow, I can’t believe how dismissive most of the comments here are. The idea of adding folding wings to existing seat dimensions could be a huge, huge improveme
by crazygringo 7y ago
Wow, I can’t believe how dismissive most of the comments here are.
The idea of adding folding wings to existing seat dimensions could be a huge, huge improvement for sleeping on flights.
No, it’s not changing or solving anything else. Yes the model is tiny. No this isn’t solving existing recline issues if you’re 6’5”. If you have incredibly broad shoulders then you might not be able to use the wings but you can still leave them folded up and it’s the same as now.
But this is still an improvement. This is a site for hackers looking to improve things. This feels like a really clever seat hack to me.
Can we actually just appreciate that it could be an improvement, rather than just rail on airline seat sizes? This is making seats better not worse.
- rpiguy 7y agoLet's say this adds 10 pounds to each seat times 150-400 seats. No way the airlines would go for it they are trying to cut weight from the planes to scrape every ounce of fuel economy out of the airframe. It is a non-starter. Airlines also have zero incentive to increase passenger comfort because most airlines operate near capacity (all flights full/overbooked) on most routes because of deregulation. You have no alternative, so why would they spend money? The best time to fly was immediately after 9/11. Airlines were failing because people stopped flying. Half of every flight was empty, and the airlines were fighting for your business adding technology, entertainment, and cutting fares. The airlines cared about you when they had to fight for your business. Within 10 years they were profitable again, at capacity again, and massively started to cut services (food, baggage, etc.) In no way am I advocating another 9/11 just to be clear. I am only reflecting on my own experiences flying.
- AJ007 7y ago2009 was pretty good too. During the next major recession/depression the cut back on both business and vacation travelers will be significant. Which, I think is ok to advocate for given we are now in the longest expansion in US history.
- menssen 7y agoIt's okay... to advocate for a major economic recession to make flying more comfortable for those of us with somewhat recession-proof skills?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Airlines also have zero incentive to increase passenger comfort Airlines seem in a constant fight for passenger comfort to me! Some have as many as five cabin tiers, attempting to make as many people as comfortable as their budgets will allow. There's competition to make the most luxurious lounges. Out-fitting of power and WiFi seems to have been effective. Whole new aircraft like the 787 are designed with passenger comfort as a priority. > In no way am I advocating another 9/11 Well at least you're being moderate then!
- zippergz 7y agoI would characterize this more as a fight for revenue maximization than passenger comfort, at least within the US for domestic flights. I fly premium classes quite a bit, and spend a lot of time in lounges. My experience is that a lot of these products launch with a bang, start out strong, but very quickly the cuts start. The airlines (or lounge operators) seem to constantly be working to see just how little they can get away with providing while still getting people to pay. International is a different game to some degree, but even there it’s not really all that unusual to see cuts to the premium products while still charging the same amount.
- notacoward 7y ago> Airlines seem in a constant fight for passenger comfort to me! Passenger comfort is what they like to talk about. That doesn't mean it's what they're really trying to optimize. They optimize for density too, but they're not about to advertise that. It's dangerous to mistake marketing for reality. So yeah, they'll add another cabin tier. Then they'll charge a fee for it and reduce the seat pitch elsewhere on their next order. It works really well when there are a few people who can pay for the upgrade out of their own pocket (most companies won't reimburse for it), but that's not really optimizing for comfort. And most people never get to use the lounges. It's good to be one of those extra-revenue types, but when I take advantage of those things I'm keenly aware that I'm exercising a form of privilege. For most people, air travel isn't getting more enjoyable.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoThere are a bunch of reasons this prototype will fail, but weight doesn't seem like the top of the list. "The seat prototype on show at the launch was a carbon fiber, lightweight design -- but the designer insists the wings could be fitted to most existing seats, whatever their material." This article has raises a number of issues. The biggest being increase of turnaround time from the complexity of cleaning, and also problem with the food service tray when wings are deployed. https://thedesignair.net/2019/12/07/interspace-the-new-seat-by-new-territory-universal-movement-challenges-the-usual-premium-economy-proposition-but-is-it-ever-going-to-take-off/ https://thedesignair.net/2019/12/07/interspace-the-new-seat-... I think if these ever make it into planes it will probably be in first class... even though there is little need for it there. Or perhaps in economy if each seat only gets a single wing.
- chrisgd 7y agoIt will be a 4th layer of premium economy!
- sonofhans 7y agoI hear what you mean about the empty planes. The best flying in my memory was in the 1970s. Everything was much more casual, less populated, and slower-paced. I remember eating freshly-fried eggs for breakfast on a 747, with metal silverware, in coach. After 9/11 I remember a lot of fear. I got searched a lot. Everyone was tense. All connection points became more isolated (e.g., you can no longer walk your family to the gate). Most non-white men I know immediately started having a worse time flying after 9/11. Now, there was also a smoking “section” in the back of the plane, and safety standards were nowhere near as robust as today, and everything was _way_ more expensive (relative to today). Sleeping was easier since the seats were wider. If the post-deregulation business model requires packing people in like little cattle, some sort of veal-cubicle isolation wings seem reasonable.
- holoduke 7y agoYes and you paid like 4000 dollars for a London New York return ticket economy class. You can still fly relatively comfortable for that price. But they call it first class now.
- Ayesh 7y agoWhat about competition? In north and south Americas, there is not much competition, but Europe and Asia has a quite tough competition. Budget airlines like Air Asia have added free in-flight WiFi with local server streaming (so you can watch movies on your phone). Malindo (a semi-budget airline) serves food and free baggage on certain routes just to compete with Air Asia. Ryan and Wizz air (Europe) have a tough competition as well, and Wizz is flying to rather better airports unlike Ryan Air.
- k_bx 7y agoThank you! From a person who falls asleep and hits his head at airplane's wall every time I sit near the window. This thing would definitely help.
- Retric 7y agoThe images shows they reduce the width between a passenger and the arm rest when the majority of people are already cramped in these seats. Really, the model in that picture must be tiny to have that kind of room. So, this may help children sleep on aircraft but the design as shown is useless to me or most other tall adults.
- crazygringo 7y agoOnly when unfolded. Folded is the same. And the point is this is for sleeping leaning against a side. You wouldn’t be using the armrests then anyways. I’m 6’1” and this design looks like a huge improvement to me.
- jmilloy 7y agoWhere do they get stored when folded? Seems like I'm either losing space left to right when unfolded or losing space front to back when folded. Is that not correct?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- habosa 7y agoAgreed! This is my dream seat. I like the aisle because I can get up but sometimes I miss window seats because you have a wall to lean against. This brings the wall to any seat. I would happily pay a little more for this seat.
- masklinn 7y agoSome of the statements in the article really weird me out though: > Who hasn't struggled to sleep on an airplane economy seat, forced to improvise a makeshift pillow out of a rolled up sweater or scarf? > A new seat design comes with an innovative solution to this inflight issue, using "padded wings" that fold out from behind both sides of the seat back -- allowing both for additional privacy and a cushioned spot to rest heads for some shut-eye. Train seats have long provided padded headrests and "horns" on the side so your head doesn't move all around while you're sleeping. On some the headrest can even be reconfigured to provide a cradle of sorts. The "blinkers" effect looks useful, as both a bit of a privacy screen and a way not to e.g. get light in your eye from the bloke across the aisle.
- alistairSH 7y agoThe last two international flights I've flown have already had small wings on the headrest. Not a big as the ones shown here, but useable at my height/size (5'7", 150lbs).
- WrongThinkerNo5 7y agoI think you are just dismissing the fact that people have genuine grievances, even if they are not only not expressing themselves properly because they probably feel utterly powerless, but also because they likely don't quite understand how their own actions lead to the current situation. Is it not legitimate to point out that they either used an old looking 6 year old girl, photoshopped the heck out of that image, or the seat is not at all to dimension of the common airplane seat. Seriously, I have broad shoulders … not even the broadest … and I have a hard time just keeping my shoulders within my space due to the laws of physics being violated by the seat widths on these planes these days. I don't think it is fair of you to just dismiss the growing frustrations towards legitimate issues, even if those expressing them are having to deal with the consequences of their own values that translated into what they supported and that then translated into actions and inactions taken by government and industry. I hate to break it to you people, but between "free" money being printed by basically all central banks, unfettered "immigration", the sellout to China and India, environmental regulation and capture that will make flying ever more expensive once the environmentalists realize just how damaging flying is, affirmative action and diversity type policies that cause all kinds of inefficiencies and conflicts and collisions in systems, among several other things … will all only make this situation far worse. Some way blather something about how new technology will develop new planes, but reality is that it will not lead to wider seats, only more seats wide. The designs are already baked into the production lines at this point and all fuselage designs ALL are designed to specs for getting more seats in width wise, not wider seats. If people wanted wider seats, they should have pushed through legislation requiring certain seat widths on human rights grounds about 10 or 15 years ago. You would never be able to get anything like that pushed through unless some wily judge is willing to throw wrenches into the aerospace industry gears.
- jenkstom 7y agoWouldn't a diversity initiative improve the situation for those of us that aren't height or width challenged?
- clairity 7y agonote that "the model" is the writer of the story. these seats are an improvement but airlines have long been user hostile, so it's understandable that folks are skeptical.
- seem_2211 7y agoI don't agree. Users are hostile to their own comfort, with the vast majority of travelers focused exclusively on price. Air travel has never been cheaper, and a less comfortable seat is a big part of that tradeoff.
- standardUser 7y agoIt's hard not to be cynical, especially when some airlines have solved this problem the old fashioned way - by providing a reasonable amount of space in the first place. I'd rather airlines find a way to match the dimensions of Jet Blue than come up with "innovations" that make their unrealistic seat dimensions slightly less miserable.
- xeromal 7y agoThe issue is how capitalism works. No one wants to pay a 1000$ for a domestic flight, but that's the only way you're getting personal space. Flights in the past were expensive, but comfortable. It's not a right to have space and affordability.
- aphistic 7y agoI'd pay $1000 for a domestic flight with leg room and a slightly wider seat. I flew first class out to San Diego recently and I would have done it on the way home as well but they wanted $2500 more for the same flight the other direction. That's just ridiculous. Flights in the past were never that expensive for the same comfort.
- selectodude 7y agoFull fare Y tickets from LAX-JFK are $2819 return. That’s how much the tickets were pre-deregulation.
- xeromal 7y agoThey were much higher man. Pick a year/decade and I'll show you how much higher they were. Flying was for the wealthy in the 60s - 70s. Don't forget inflation. After deregulation, prices dropped by 50% or so. Most airlines do have a Comfort+ that is pretty affordable and allows you more room and a better seat.
- alistairSH 7y agoDulles to O'hare (return fight) is ~$250-$300 economy. Business class is $600-$700. (both found using Google Flights) So, you can already do what you want (get leg room and comfort for $1000 or less).
- logfromblammo 7y agoI'd appreciate that this possibly could make airline economy flights better, if I believed that airlines had nonzero interest in improving the experiences they offer their economy passengers. Airlines are interested in three things: more paid passengers in the same cabin volume, less weight per seat, and less turnaround cost on the ground. I'm not sure how the new seat design serves any of those factors.