4 ms·
bug: 4=x^4 does not imply 4=∞(x), therefore you can't 'go back up' in the reasoning. The psychological core of the "paradox" is that ∞(√2) actually equals 2, b
by lloeki 16y ago
bug: 4=x^4 does not imply 4=∞(x), therefore you can't 'go back up' in the reasoning.
The psychological core of the "paradox" is that ∞(√2) actually equals 2, bringing credence to the second part. This does not actually makes the first part a valid proof of x=√2 either (as the bug still applies). All that it proves is that IF 2=∞(x) then it MUST be √2. Remains to be proven is that n(√2) converges when n->∞, and does indeed converge towards 2.
For the second part to be proven false, it is sufficient to show that convergent values are originating from [e^-e, e^1/e] and that for x in [e^-e, e^1/e] we have ∞(x) < 2.8. Therefore ∞(x) can't equal 4, ever.
- amalcon 16y agoThat's not quite what's going on here. The manipulations show that, if 4=x^(x^(...)), 4=x^4. The mistake is in beginning with the assumption that the former equation has a solution. If it doesn't, any manipulations that assume it does are invalid to begin with. Most people aren't exposed to the idea that an equation could have no solution all by itself, basically because polynomial equations always do.
- lloeki 16y agoWell that's what I meant (or rather wanted to mean). I should have phrased the whole thing differently, but I'm still wrestling with English as a language, and rarely if ever used it in mathematics! I should definitely write more.