5 ms·
I was talking to my friend about this the other day. He's an executive at an ad company (not Google). He had an interesting take on this: Yes, it is in fact
by jedberg 7y ago
I was talking to my friend about this the other day. He's an executive at an ad company (not Google). He had an interesting take on this:
Yes, it is in fact working and breaks targeting and retargeting. But what is the outcome of that?
The CPMs (how much the website makes) are 10x higher for re/targeted ads. So as they stop working, do you think the website will cut their revenue? No, they'll either put up a paywall, or put 10x more ads on their page. And those ads will frustrate you even more, because they aren't targeted to you.
And in the meantime, Google and Facebook will still know everything about you. It's just the smaller websites who suffer by not getting ad revenue. And they weren't even getting your personal data in the first place.
I still side with Apple on this one, but he has a good point. Overall what they are doing will probably just make things worse for everyone that isn't Apple, Google, and Facebook.
- manigandham 7y agoThe problem is they had a great solution with advertiser ID which is already used in apps. Expose that to websites and they would get a good compromise for both sides.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> No, they'll either put up a paywall. Personally, I think I'm fine with that, provided the paywalls get cheaper—right now, they're all very clearly more expensive than what you'd make in ad revenue. Of the two options, paying content creators for what they produce seems much more "healthy" for society. > or put 10x more ads on their page. If the site becomes impossible to browse, I will leave. > And those ads will frustrate you even more, because they aren't targeted to you. I don't find targeted ads any less annoying than untargetted ones.
- Zanni 7y agoI like targeted ads, but I want them targeted to the content I'm consuming, not me personally. If I'm reading a blog or article on rock climbing, then, yeah, show me ads for all the gear. I'm interested. But don't show me an ad for an Instant Pot because I googled it last week. That's creepy.
- elliekelly 7y agoI agree. From what I understand this is the DDG model. I don’t hate ads, sometimes they’re even helpful, but I do hate being tracked.
- lexicality 7y agoAdverts that relate to the content they're next to are contextual ads, rather than targeted ads. They're apparently not very good for advertisers.
- criddell 7y agoThey are the only ethical kind.
- Ensorceled 7y agoThey are not "as good". Advertiser are addicted to demo, behavioural and interest targeting because that is what Google and Facebook gave them.
- summerlight 7y agoContextual targeting is happening, but it doesn't perform well as behavioral one yet while the risk is much higher for advertisers/publishers with the current technology (e.g. gun ads on a mass gun shooting news). With a sufficient technology, the situation can improve though.
- alwillis 7y agoThat’s how Brave works—using zero-knowledge proofs, it uses your browsing history to inform its opt-in ad network on what ads should be shown to you. That info doesn’t leave your device. And if you opt-in, you get paid using their cryptocurrency Basic Attention Token: https://www.theverge.com/2019/11/13/20962085/brave-beta-1-0-privacy-browser-chrome-firefox-safari-ad-block-tracker https://www.theverge.com/2019/11/13/20962085/brave-beta-1-0-...
- saagarjha 7y agoWhy does it need my entire browsing history? The example given above didn't ask for that.
- signal11 7y agoI don’t get targeted ads. They’re quite dumb. If I look at product X, ads for product X follow me around the web, which isn’t that useful because I’ve already done my research and am not quite ready to hit “buy” no matter how many ads you show. Ads for similar products I might be interested in, but I’ve not seen too many of those served up by these ad networks. Untargeted ads at least might show me something new and interesting.
- manigandham 7y agoThat's not how they work. What you're seeing is the issue with not having data shared between networks and the resulting poor targeting. Retargeting has better results than any other type of targeting but unfortunately there's a gap between the ecommerce systems knowing you bought something and the ad networks used to market those ads. It's easy to drop a pixel and say you looked at a product, but it's much harder to let that same network know that you're no longer interested for whatever reason. Add in complexities like multiple devices, browsers, ecommerce stores, payment methods, and it only gets harder. This is usually why retargeting is much better with smaller direct-to-consumer companies which tend to have a single customer database and payment method to sync from.
- Zak 7y agoAmazon has been repeatedly showing me office chair casters as a suggestion after I bought a set on Amazon. Despite having much better information on things I actually spend money on than the average ad network (all my devices have adblockers), Amazon isn't clever enough to figure out that I'm probably done with that product category for years.
- manigandham 7y agoTo explain how this happens will take several pages of notes on the complexities of ad serving that are the exact opposite of "not clever enough". A summary is that your adblocking may have an impact on syncing stats, your purchases are not unique enough to matter for that category, serving some ad is better than serving no ad, and it maybe better to show you that impression however worthless than to bother with something else considering the auction dynamics at that point in time.
- dave5104 7y ago> And those ads will frustrate you even more, because they aren't targeted to you. I would have thought that the frustrating part of an advertisement is the presentation of the ad itself--not necessarily its content.
- jedberg 7y agoI actually find myself clicking on targeted ads occasionally because they are so relevant. In that sense, I'd say it's the content that makes it less frustrating.
- hk__2 7y ago> It's just the smaller websites who suffer by not getting ad revenue. I’m ok with anything that frustrates people who get money from ads.
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoI'm not nearly as anti-ad as many people I've interacted with on HN and Twitter. I like the idea of getting free-to-me content supported by ads. I resisted running ad blockers for a very, very long time. But. The ads just got bigger. And bigger. And more intrusive. They approached 50% of the visible content (and that's on the desktop, not mobile). They played more video. They played more music. They started blocking the content I was trying to read, all in an effort to get me to click. So I gave in. I run an ad-blocker, too. Your friend inadvertently pinned what I personally think is the original sin of online advertising: measuring an ad's success through the number of clicks it gets. Ads in other mediums aren't designed with the idea that the only successful ad is one that makes you go AAAAH MUST GO BUY RIGHT NOW RIGHT NOW DROP EVERYTHING AAAAAAAA... but 20 years ago, some dingdong decided that because it was possible to measure "direct engagement" with ads on the web in a way you couldn't with TV or print, it was appropriate to measure ads that way. Think of how different the web might be if, instead, we'd just sold ads by the number of visits to an article the ad is on... or better yet, by the number of visits to the web site, period. "But that's not an exact measure! We can't tell if it's really worth what we're being charged!" You also have no way of knowing whether or not that full-page color ad in the New Yorker is "really worth" what you're being charged, but you know what? You got along fine that way for decades. You did. Your business was fine.
- jedberg 7y ago> So I gave in. I run an ad-blocker, too. Me too. I worked for a company that made almost all of it's revenue from advertising. It felt hypocritical to run an ad-blocker. But it just got so bad I had to do it. I'm just worried about what will happen to the web for all the people who don't run ad-blockers. I care about them too, especially since they are the customers in a lot of cases, and if they go away from the web completely because it's so bad, what then? > Think of how different the web might be if, instead, we'd just sold ads by the number of visits to an article the ad is on... or better yet, by the number of visits to the web site, period. That's actually how many ads are sold. By CPM (cost per thousand impressions).
- chipotle_coyote 7y ago
- summerlight 7y agoApple is not willing to understand the whole dynamic in the ads market, including publishers trying to game with the system all time. I've observed the worst on what those publishers can do and am pretty sure about that they will find out a "creative" way to make up for the revenue loss. Of course, I'm not saying this will be user-friendly; publishers tend to be more "creative" when it tries to rather exploit users.
- saagarjha 7y agoThe engineers at Apple are well aware of the games that adtech plays.
- summerlight 7y agoDo you work for/with Apple regard to this issue? I followed discussions with WebKit devs and had an impression that they don't really care about the ecosystem but only Apple users. It seems they had never reached out to publishers/advertisers in the design phase of ITP. Later, they prepared a crappy conversion tracking mechanism to compensate the loss, but this design also had never involved the ecosystem.
- saagarjha 7y agoI do not currently work for Apple on this, but you can read about the ways Intelligent Tracking Prevention has changed to adapt to the ecosystem on the WebKit blog: https://webkit.org/blog/category/privacy/ https://webkit.org/blog/category/privacy/. I was under the impression that the ad click attribution work (which I think is what you’re talking about) is being proposed as a standard and is open for comments right now.
- summerlight 7y agoI understand how ITP works, its intention and goals since this had a significant impact on my work. And assuming a good intention on Apple's side, this makes me pretty confident that Apple doesn't want to put significant investment of its resource on studying how the ads ecosystem works (and of course they don't have a strong motivation to do so). On browser-side conversion tracking, I can say that this will unlikely be adopted by advertisers/publishers in the current form. This is not my own opinion, but more about general feeling across advertisers/publishers that I've met.
- driverdan 7y ago> Yes, it is in fact working and breaks targeting and retargeting. But what is the outcome of that? Improved privacy. The rest of what you said is irrelevant.
- Terretta 7y agoYour proposed tradeoff space are not the only two options. As a ‘third way’, you can match ads to real content, and have audience interests and advertiser interests aligned. Folks who try this, find it works, in some cases only a percentage point or two worse than high end retargeting, and in most cases, better than retargeting when sold by third party or retargeting across run of site. EDIT: CPC (cost-per-click) and CPM (cost-per-thousand impressions) are both fine when matching ads and content. For instance, the ‘affiliate link’ business is predicated on the idea that inline clicks on products mentioned in content are so valuable as to be individually worth a piece of the actual sale.
- buboard 7y agoaffiliate sites are created purposefully with persuasive text specifically to rank high on google and cause sales. in the generic case, a website would have to specify its own advertising-keywords, because contextual mismatching the audience. Regardless, i think an ad service with only contextual ads will either fail, or end up implementing the wheel (targeted ads) to survive. tracking adtech does lead to more effective, less intrusive ads in the average case. The tech that will dethrone google will be a service that matches buyers and sellers better than google.
- visarga 7y ago> As a ‘third way’, you can match ads to real content, and have audience interests and advertiser interests aligned. Doesn't work because the advertisers usually want to sell something different from what the majority of users are interested in. If they strictly respected the interests of the users most of the ads would disappear.
- scarface74 7y agoNo, they'll either put up a paywall That would be a great alternative. I buy Apple stuff because the business model is simple. I give them money and they give me stuff.
- buboard 7y agoi dont know any computer or phone manufacturer that gives phones for ads.
- scarface74 7y agoAll consumer PCs except for Macs are subsidized by ads - the Intel Inside, Powered by Nvidia stickers and the crapware that comes on PCs. Android phones are also subsidized by manufacture and carrier crapware. Not to mention that Android manufacturers get Google Play Services free in exchange for Google ads and analytics. The most popular streaming media devices - Rokus - have hard coded buttons that go to the highest bidder. I have a Roku remote right now with an RDio button and there are some auth a Blockbuster button. Not to mention half the home screen on Roku devices are taken up with ads. Microsoft has ads in Windows 10 and Skype.