4 ms·
How has this been so effective, when Panopticlick still says my Safari browser has "a nearly-unique fingerprint"? (And based on what I've read from other users'
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
How has this been so effective, when Panopticlick still says my Safari browser has "a nearly-unique fingerprint"? (And based on what I've read from other users's experience, this is normal.)
- nielsbot 7y agoI'd love to know this too--maybe fingerprinting isn't yet being used most places? Or maybe fingerprinting isn't that useful without additional cookie tracking?
- imposterr 7y agoFrom what I understand, a lot of the ad networks still work off cookies, they haven't moved to using fingerprinting yet. I think as browsers implement more anti-tracking features they may start to though.
- harikb 7y agoThey say "nearly-unique" - I get an odds of '1 in 50,000'. Granted, that may be enough combined with IP or some other factor as a transient/session cookie. However the hash might change as soon as a plugin or some dependency is updated.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoCombine my Canvas fingerprint (which a plugin update won't change) with my rough location (based on IP address), and I have to imagine you'd get very, very close to identifying me.
- gruez 7y agoCanvas fingerprints are probably the same between other iphones of the same model and ios version. So unless you use a rare model and/or rare ios version, there's probably at least a few dozen people with the same fingerprint/ip range combination as you.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoMy understanding—only because another HN commenter told me as much, many months back—was that even the exact same model hardware would return different canvas fingerprints due to silicon differences. Not true?
- saagarjha 7y agoThat sounds unlikely. I'm sure there is some variation due to differences in OSes and GPUs, but there are surely enough iPhones with each to make it nothing more than supplementary entropy.
- gruez 7y agoThat seems implausible unless there's analog logic involved. With digital logic a bit is either a 1 or a 0, and any "variations" (eg. a 0 where it was supposed to be a 1) would be considered flaws as they can dramatically skew the end result (eg. the MSB of an integer being flipped, or one of the bits in the exponent of a float). As far as I know, there aren't any analog logic involved in a rasterization pipeline.
- jedberg 7y agoWhen you load Panopticlick, you'll notice it takes a minute or so to fingerprint you. That's a pretty long time and a lot of CPU. Re/Targeted ads require the decision to be made in milliseconds, including network transit time. They just don't have the time to fingerprint you on every request. They could do it once, but then they are back to the problem of having to set a cookie to keep track of you after that.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThanks, that actually explains a lot!
- 1propionyl 7y agoIt's not accurate though. See other replies.
- repsilat 7y ago> Re/Targeted ads require the decision to be made in milliseconds, including network transit time If they're served on page-load when a user first visits a site, but I guess a significant minority are also requested+served in the middle of your newspaper article two minutes after page load, or in the middle of your Youtube video, or a refreshing sticky-footer ad, or just the next page loaded on a site.
- surround 7y ago>When you load Panopticlick, you'll notice it takes a minute or so to fingerprint you. No, it takes a minute because it’s trying to load trackers in order to test your adblocker. Fingerprinting itself takes only a moment. Try TorZillaPrint: the results are instantaneous. https://ghacksuserjs.github.io/TorZillaPrint/TorZillaPrint.html https://ghacksuserjs.github.io/TorZillaPrint/TorZillaPrint.h... In practice, good content blockers (i.e. uBlock Origin) block most fingerprinting scripts. I don’t know whether Safari’s includes this.
- manigandham 7y agoIt's mobile Safari that is hard to fingerprint and getting harder with each version. Most adtech still runs off cookies to share data and store identifiers and those have been basically eradicated. Having to fingerprint every pageview also creates latency and still isn't that deterministic so everything will need to shift to probabilistic and contextual targeting. That's a hard change to make for most legacy networks.
- paulmd 7y agoAren't cellular providers tagging connections with unique identifiers to make targeting possible?
- manigandham 7y agoTelecoms like Verizon and ATT have their own adtech companies and were doing this, but regulations and encryption technologies have disabled most of it. IPv6 with probabilistic modeling comes pretty close though.
- Someone1234 7y agoNot over HTTPS they aren't.
- gruez 7y agoMy guess would be sample bias. ie. there aren't too many people going to Panopticlick from their iphones, so it thinks your iPhone is unique.
- mobjack 7y agoFingerprinting is much harder in reality than Panopticlick makes you believe. For example, if you update your browser or add a new plugin, you can look like a new person so it makes it harder to find a match. A cookie would not change through that event. Enough people have the same fingerprint that it limits its effectiveness. Maybe you can only reliably identify 40% of your user base that way. It is like using your IP address as an identifier. For some people it can be 100% accurate, but others switch networks or share an IP with multiple other people which limits its usefulness. What ends up happening is that companies will correlate IP address with other fingerprint information to get a probabilistic match but that is complex and still has flaws.
- baroffoos 7y agoNot sure if this is the case but it would be possible to fool fingerprinting by randomizing parts of the browser so each request has a unique fingerprint which isn't useful for tracking.
- greggman2 7y agobecause pantoptclick is wrong! you can be in California and using say an iPhoneX and it will tell you you're one in 500k. If you calculate the number of people with their iPhone set to English in the PST timezone (the only things there is to distinguish one iPhoneX from another) and then you divide that by the pantoptclick number you get it's claiming there are only 10-100 iPhoneXs in all of Seattle Metro Area, San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles Metro Area, and San Diego Metro Area combined. Clearly wrong
- SAI_Peregrinus 7y agoIt's not wrong, it's just potentially misleading. > Your browser fingerprint appears to be unique among the 251,543 tested in the past 45 days. It only counts against those other people who visited panopticlick, and that in the last 45 days. That's explicitly stated, but hidden in the click-through for details section. There are also things it can't detect, such as the existence of the Cookie Auto-Delete extension. So it thinks cookies are enabled and can be used for tracking, but in reality they get deleted whenever I close a tab (and links to new domains get opened in new tabs). Or user-agent randomization, which will make your fingerprint more unique but less useful for tracking.