7 ms·
Many reasons to be dubious about bitcoin and its liquidity and how much wash trading goes on, but it seems a bit odd to judge it by the amount of outstanding co
by rwmj 7y ago
Many reasons to be dubious about bitcoin and its liquidity and how much wash trading goes on, but it seems a bit odd to judge it by the amount of outstanding coin being traded. How much gold that exists is actively traded? Or even the same question for a typical company stock?
- aidenn0 7y ago100s of billions of dollars of gold is traded each day.
- Findeton 7y agoOn options maybe.
- rwmj 7y agoThat could be the same gold being traded multiple times per day. What % of all gold extracted from the ground is traded annually?
- JamesBarney 7y agoWhy does it matter if it's the same gold? Say a 100 people each own a 100 gold pieces. And they all buy and sell 100 gold pieces worth of goods and services per day.(10,000 gold pieces are traded) Why would it matter if this is physically the same gold coin traded 10,000 times or 10,000 gold coins being traded once?
- rwmj 7y agoBecause the WSJ article specifically talks about the number of bitcoins traded as a percentage of the whole number of coins mined. This is why I keep asking for this percentage for other assets like gold and stocks.
- tachion 7y agoIs it actually gold that's being traded, or papers/promises/options/whatever-else-but-physical-gold saying 'x amount of gold' is actually traded?
- paulddraper 7y agoWell, physical Bitcoins aren't being traded either. Because there aren't physical Bitcoins.
- hndamien 7y agoActual custody is being traded though.
- paulddraper 7y agoSame for gold (again legally, not physically).
- hndamien 7y agoFor gold, typically ownership is traded, not custody.
- scrooched_moose 7y agoBecause Bitcoin is (at least theoretically) a currency. You're comparing it to a commodity or store of value. The power of a currency is the ability to trade it for goods and services. If that is no longer happening with Bitcoin it has morphed into something else entirely.
- rwmj 7y agoI've never owned or traded bitcoin, but as I understand it the main attraction is that it's like the gold standard (of course for people who don't understand why the gold standard was a bad idea).
- JamesBarney 7y agoExactly, like a currency on the gold standard. But not an asset like gold.
- ur-whale 7y agoIt's nothing like the gold standard. What made the gold standard a bad idea does not apply to Bitcoin.
- this_user 7y agoYou mean that there is a cap on the supply that cannot keep pace with the growth of the real economy?
- noxer 7y agoThe cap is irrelevant. Instead of printing more the value per unit goes up in the end it does the same it adjust for growth just fine. It's just not practical for a fiat currency to change it's value depending on the economy situation. If for example the USD would have a fix cap and its value would swing with the economy, people would speculate with it. At peaks everyone would want to buy and at the lows everyone would pay salaries and debs etc. the growth isn't the problem the swings and uncertainty about the value makes it unusable for a currency. Bitcoin doesn't have this problem is kinda like gold no one really want to pay with it (beside the bitcoin maxis).
- axlee 7y agoThat's one of the standard metrics to judge any currency. Bitcoin is not advertised as an asset but as a digital currency. But it has clearly become primarily an asset, given the minimal uses of it as a currency.
- paulddraper 7y agoOnce transaction fees exceeded $20 back in 2017, it was pretty clear Bitcoin was an asset not a currency. Horrible properties for a currency. Usual properties for a collectible asset.
- cwkoss 7y agoI'd argue that IRS tax treatment of Bitcoin as an asset (and thus making every currency-like purchase - even when exchanging for good or services - a taxable event) is another significant factor. Fees may have made this inevitable, but having to deal with taxes has definitely made me much more wary of using it for small purchases. Bitcoin tax accounting is tedious, and I think once a company solves non-custodial record keeping for the purposes of automated tax accounting, it will increase velocity of spending.
- paulddraper 7y agoThe IRS treats essentially everything ownable as an asset: gold, paper currency, bitcoin, art, postage stamps. You obviously never pay capital gains tax on USD, because it never changes value relative to USD. AFAIK a Bitcoin is no different than a Euro tax-wise.
- cwkoss 7y agoI am not an accountant and may be wrong, but if a US citizen exchanges $1000 USD to euro, and then euro appreciates 10%, and then they spend that euro to make a purchase, I was under the impression that that purchase is not subject to capital gains. Exchanging back to USD would be, but I thought currency classification exempted cap gains on purchases of goods and services. Am I wrong? Have never held any significant amount of foreign currency, so have never dealt with this personally.
- nonanonymous 7y agoYou can google any ticker symbol and find the volume relative to the outstanding shares.
- ur-whale 7y ago> How much gold that exists is actively traded? A better analogy would be: how much gold is actually being physically moved from one vault to another.