3 ms·
If your college has any proper security on access ports, they'll be limited to one MAC address per physical port, and hopefully a decent 802.1x setup
by walrus01 7y ago
If your college has any proper security on access ports, they'll be limited to one MAC address per physical port, and hopefully a decent 802.1x setup
- tinco 7y agoWhy would 1 mac per port be proper security? Seems needlessly restrictive and ineffective to me.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoNAT for IPs may be everywhere, but NAT for MAC addresses is inconceivable.
- mercora 7y agoif you use a cheap router instead of a switch the far end will only see one MAC address which is the one of the router. doing NAT then is as easy as it could be. You could literally use just about any router out of the box without even configuring anything. you can also add an ethernet switch behind this device easily. only limiting a port to a single MAC is therefore somewhat pointless. you would prohibit valid use cases (adding a switch) without hindering any nefarious user (guy with a cheap router). Also, NAT for MAC addresses is a thing although not necessarily the most useful approach in this case...
- jrockway 7y agoA lot of people think trusted L3 is a valid security solution.
- jlgaddis 7y ago> an airgapped network for security classes
- Godel_unicode 7y agoWait till he finds out that people frequently use multiple VMs with their own MAC addresses on a given physical box. Especially in the kind of lab where people are working on security projects. Edit: or that security includes availability in addition to confidentiality and integrity
- milankragujevic 7y agoEh, at work I either have to assign them pre-approved MAC addresses or get approval for VM MACs, or just use pretend my PC is a router and all VMs get a 100...* IP (10...* is used for the network already).
- rovr138 7y agoYou can usually do NAT and Bridged. NAT won’t have issues. Bridged will. Regarding the IP range, on most most hypervisors that’s configurable.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoWhy rfc6598 space instead of one of the other 1918 ranges? I would expect pretending to be a cgn on an internal network to blow up in spectacular fashion.
- milankragujevic 7y agoErm, the VMs see CGNAT, but it doesn't mean anything in my case, but still let's me access other PCs on the company Intranet on 10.x.x.x
- walrus01 7y agoI think he means doing NAT on his PC itself (such as is the default network configuration on virtualbox), where it doesn't ordinarily matter what private IP range the VMs are located in. VMs get DHCP leases and a default gateway from the host. The host presents only one IP address and MAC to what it's physically plugged into.
- braindeath 7y agoOne MAC per port is very low yield, won’t do anything to stop even a mildly sophisticated attacker, and often just makes life more difficult than it needs to be. Especially for a college network where any notion that the general network is “secure” is a complete joke.
- walrus01 7y agoIt's not meant to be a comprehensive security plan, but rather a very easy thing to have configured on each port, to stop people from plugging $20 8 port dumb switches into managed infrastructure.
- braindeath 7y agoBut not a $30 wireless router. And again there’s no need to be so draconian on something like a ResNet.