6 ms·
You don't have a right to make money by manipulating impressionable people into buying things that they don't need. Or maybe you do because of free speech, but
by gpm 7y ago
You don't have a right to make money by manipulating impressionable people into buying things that they don't need.
Or maybe you do because of free speech, but you definitely don't have a right to have other people not try and stop you from succeeding.
- umvi 7y agoAnd you don't have a right to have your cake and eat it too. It's astonishing how many people on HN believe it is okay to shaft the sponsors of the content they enjoy and consume. What ever happened to "don't bite the hand that feeds you?"
- iicc 7y agoI object to someone trying to influence me, just because they're paid to. Don't you?
- wongarsu 7y agoThen don't watch sponsored channels?
- tetris11 7y agoAnd if the only fast video sharing site is teeming with these kind of videos? What would a sane man do?
- umvi 7y agoSupport the content creator with Patreon and then skip the in-video sponsorship with a clear conscience.
- ajayyy 7y agoMaybe my extension will convince some youtubers to offer non sponsored videos on patreon. That would be the dream result of this extension. Even nebula (CGP Grey and Kurzgesagt's steaming platform) sadly doesn't enforce this.
- zamadatix 7y agoSo I pay for YouTube Premium. I also have a Twitch Turbo, a Netflix 4k family, a Disney+ bundle with enhanced Hulu, HBO, Amazon Prime, Spotify Premium, and I'm sure others I'm forgetting. I also have a few of my favorite creators on Patreon directly. I donate more monthly to free/open software than I spend on licensed software/games. Am I really giving the shaft to the content because I want to skip the ad segment or are they giving me the shaft for trying to force ads on me even though I've already paid for the content twice? I don't want to hear your catchy jingle, get your brand stuck in my head, or hear about the same damn 3 services 1000 times. I just want to pay for content and watch it. It's not possible without something like this. Is everybody using this service like me? No. That doesn't make them wrong either though, it's not like there was an alternative option they could have picked that would have let them avoid these segments "officially".
- dominotw 7y agowouldn't that be stealing by defintion though? Get something for nothing.
- gpm 7y agoStealing involves depriving someone something that they are entitled to. That is not happening here, so no. This is far farther from stealing than even copyright infringement, and even that does not qualify. (It would be approximately equivalent to copyright infringement in the case that the creator only gave you access to the videos upon you signing a contract that required you to view the ads to watch the video).
- michaelmrose 7y agoStealing isn't getting something for nothing its a crime based on the inherently rivalrous nature of physical things. You and I can't both eat the same sandwich or park in the same space. We decided to adopt a complex set of rules for parking spots and sandwiches to keep people from settling matters for themselves by punching and kicking each other so we can go about all the other fun things that make civilization go. Re-purposing it to mean me doing or not doing something that will profit you is intellectually dishonest.
- lordleft 7y agoWhile I'm not partial to ads, it costs money to make content. If you don't want to pay for that content, it seems unseemly to deny the content creator the income stream they've created, instead of just not viewing the content. Of course ads are getting more and more obnoxious, so there's a lot of gray here, especially as I'm finding mobile sites almost unusable thanks to advertising.
- gpm 7y agoIf the social "contract" that the content creator is offering is that you must watch the ads to view the content, I'd be somewhat partial to your argument. As an example MLG does (used to do?) that, and I just didn't watch their content as a result. That's not the social contract that either youtube itself or youtubers are offering. You can skip the ads, they make no attempt to block you from watching the video if you skip the ads.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIt's not even gray. There is no obligation to view their attempts at manipulation.