3 ms·
Ah ha -- this isn't to skip ads, it's to crowdsource the time segments in YouTube videos where sponsored content is part of the video itself, to skip the segmen
by crazygringo 7y ago
Ah ha -- this isn't to skip ads, it's to crowdsource the time segments in YouTube videos where sponsored content is part of the video itself, to skip the segment itself.
I love it technically... but sadly I have hard time believing it will ever work in practice, though maybe I'm just a cynic. :(
Simply because it needs a dedicated base of people always keeping up with all the videos coming out each day who actually will go to the work of rewinding, tagging, fast-forwarding, tagging again, continuing when all they really want to do is just sit back watching a video.
Crowdsourcing for things like adblockers or Wikipedia work because the content changes slowly and is evergreen. But popular YouTube videos rotate very quickly and then sink into a long tail.
I'd love to be proven wrong, however. :)
(One way of possibly increasing adoption, however: I'd love if the extension automatically ended videos when they jump into the "subscribe now!" trailer at the end, especially for talk show segments, and immediately jumped to the next video in the playlist if there is one. They're always the same length for each show, so very easy to keep up-to-date.)
- faissaloo 7y agoI've been using it and it's made my YouTube experience much better.
- tetris11 7y agoSame. I have been using it for a few months now, both as a user and a contributor (of times). It has not let me down once, and genuinely makes YouTube tolerable again
- ALittleLight 7y agoPerhaps this is just phase one, to build a dataset out of YouTube videos and sponsored promotions. Phase two could be training a classifier on the dataset. Then, the classifier watches a few minutes ahead of the user, skipping any in-content ads.
- gpm 7y agoIt would have to be quite the classifier, since the advertisers would be able to test against it and try to break it. False positives would heavily impact usability.
- crazygringo 7y agoOn the one hand, classification might be a bit easier given that YouTube auto-generates transcripts -- so it only has to work on text. On the other hand, I just don't think it's possible -- it's going to have way too many false positives, because there are already so many unsponsored YouTube videos that review products or tell their customers to buy things, and there's very little actual text involved in the sponsorship segment. And you've got to 1) identify that there's a sponsored segment at all which is hard enough, but then 2) accurately detect where it starts and ends, which is even harder. And if this ever did manage to work on existing videos, it just turns into an arms race which neutralizes it -- sponsors will require content creators to be more creative in how they embed the sponsorship so that they only get sponsored as long as the segment makes it past the classifier.
- ajayyy 7y agoSponsorblock developer here. The best part is that I made the database completely public, so someone else can do "phase 2" without me even having to be involved :)