3 ms·
While you could argue about: > install packages for a single user because of the security angle, Not allowing this: > install multiple versions of the same p
by oblio 7y ago
While you could argue about:
> install packages for a single user
because of the security angle, Not allowing this:
> install multiple versions of the same package
is completely indefensible.
Who are you, package manager, to decide that I shouldn't be able to use different versions of the same package? Do you know more about my context than I do?
- spion 7y agoI don't see the security angle either. You could design the system in a way that makes it able to force updates into the individual user's broken packages. Heck, it shouldn't even be connected to a user - it's just that every user should be able to install a package, and what install might mean is * compartmentalized side-effects (not per-user even - users might decide they want multiple compartments for different apps) and * a shared storage area for all the packages and their versions (i.e. Nix)
- eeZah7Ux 7y ago> Who are you, package manager, to decide that I shouldn't be able to use different versions of the same package? That's one of main point of a distribution, rather that simply throwing software on a hard drive. The maintainers have to work hard to guarantee that a specific set of packages and version work well together. Well enough for most users to deploy 99% of the packages without surprises. And then backport security updates (often faster than upstream), for 3 years, often 5. And various companies provide longer term updates and maintenance. Oh, and provide license checking and vetting. Turns out that it's a lot of work and no serious distribution would consider supporting multiple version of packages while guaranteeing the same level of quality. > Do you know more about my context than I do? Given your statements about distributions... most likely yes.
- oblio 7y ago> Given your statements about distributions... most likely yes. Hello there, ad hominem. Linux distributions are overreaching. They should offer those services for core software. I should be able to install Inkscape 0.91 and 0.92 at the same time, easily.