3 ms·
Can I be controversial and ask what justifies such expenses? Why is this game so important that it needs to be up and running so badly? From what I've seen so
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
Can I be controversial and ask what justifies such expenses? Why is this game so important that it needs to be up and running so badly?
From what I've seen so far the "game" (if you can even call it that) highlights the weaknesses of GPT-2 much more than its strengths (the model's answers to user actions are random, the story is incoherent, the world is inconsistent). I don't get the feeling it was setup to demonstrate _weakness_ though. I think it was meant to demonstrate strngths.
I suppose it's just advertising for the BYU Perception, Control and Cognition Lab, but it sounds awfuly expensive for advertising for an academic group.
- qxnqd 7y agoWhy justify it, when it's public money? It's free!
- drewbug 7y ago> Brigham Young University is a private research university located in Provo, Utah and owned by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mola 7y agoWelcome to the hype cycle
- Tenoke 7y ago>Can I be controversial and ask what justifies such expenses? Why is this game so important that it needs to be up and running so badly? Most popular Games, Movies, etc. cost orders of magnitude more. The value is typically entertainment.
- megla_ 7y agopseudointellectuallity: the post
- catacombs 7y agoThe hype is not rocket science: The game is a lot of fun, and a lot of people in the RPG communities are excited about this.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI agree that it's entertaining and I see the appeal to role-players. It appeals to me, too (well, I'm a gamer). What I don't understand is how come someone's paying $10k a day to keep it running if it's not really returning anything. $10k is not a small sum. It sounds like a heck of a lot to pay to keep a game running just because people find it fun. Basically, I don't think I've heard of anything like this before. Usually when people put something on the internet for free either it's very cheap for them, or they have a way to recoup the costs, e.g. by serving ads or asking for donations etc. To just throw money at something that doesn't return anything is very uncommon.
- CathedralBorrow 7y agoWhat a cynical input into the conversation. First you assume that this project even existing is some kind of statement about how important it is; a connection I can't make myself unless I try to be extremely cynical. If you actually look at the project website you'll see that the main mirrors are currently down due to high download costs. Then you smugly dismiss the entire project as a GPT-2 weakness highlighter, but not without wrapping it in some passive aggressive faux concern ("Oh is this trying to be good? Silly me, I thought this was a showcase for how to be bad!"). And then you assume that this game that thousands of people (although none of them were you) have enjoyed playing is probably an advertisement for an academic lab. Despite there being almost no evidence for it. Can I be controversial now and ask: What's with the bile?
- hombre_fatal 7y agoHN is the only community I know of that has people that will not only call out this kind of attitude, but will do so in an absolutely scathing, bedrock-hitting way. I hope this is something that never changes about HN. That was a pleasure to read.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> First you assume that this project even existing is some kind of statement about how important it is; a connection I can't make myself unless I try to be extremely cynical. That would be cynical, but I did not make this assumption. I questioned the justification of the high cost to maintain the project, not the existence of the project per se. I did not doubt that people enjoyed the project but, again, I don't understand how a research lab justifies paying such a high cost to provide entertainment. If the project could be maintained for free then I would not have any questions. But if a lab is spending $10k to keep a game running then yes, I have to wonder why. I do think that the game shows up GPT-2's weaknesses. Do you really think it's "bile" or "cynical" to recognise weaknesses of a technology? Perhaps I'm cynical to assume it's advertisement. I apologise if that's the case. Note also that accusing me of bile is a personal comment that I think is unnecessary.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago