4 ms·
"Angered by the bank’s reply, Teich contacted the Guardian for help. We asked it to reconsider his case, and in an almost immediate U-turn, it has now agreed to
by perl4ever 7y ago
"Angered by the bank’s reply, Teich contacted the Guardian for help. We asked it to reconsider his case, and in an almost immediate U-turn, it has now agreed to pay all his legal fees, and has offered him £750 in compensation."
I dunno, this sounds fake.
Financial institutions make mistakes all the time, and if the scenario here really did happen, what do you spend £46,000 on? Lawyers are expensive, but they don't charge that much to send a nasty letter. That's like months of billable hours.
- detaro 7y agoGetting apparently multiple court orders, as the article describes, is probably a bit more work and fees than "send a nasty letter"
- perl4ever 7y agoMultiple court orders? Does the procedure involve large amounts of unmarked bills for the British equivalent of a judge? £46,000 is obviously not "a bit more" than the fee for writing a letter. Why would someone assume the Guardian doesn't make up stories like these? Are they more reliable than the Sun?
- matthewheath 7y agoNot sure what the "British equivalent of a judge" is other than, well, a judge. Court claims are expensive. This ultimately would've been heard in the High Court and the claimant would want decent counsel to represent him as well as a team of solicitors and other legal professionals to research and handle the correspondence — that's the bulk of the fees. Then there's the cost of the application itself. The fee for starting a case is 5% of the amount for claims worth between £10,000 and £200,000. In this case, that's almost £10,000 gone immediately on the court fee. For one case. There's also a court fee for the initial hearing and the return hearing for the freezing order. Not sure how £12k was spent on the first case—article doesn't mention which court and suggests the High Court was only involved in the second case, but I suspect that isn't true.
- perl4ever 7y ago"The fee for starting a case is 5% of the amount for claims worth between £10,000 and £200,000." I don't believe it. If this was really the way the courts over there worked, then nobody would make disparaging comments about the American legal system.
- matthewheath 7y agoWhat's not to believe? You can look at the cost of filing a claim in the High Court online for yourself. I apologise for not making it clear — that fee is specifically for filing a claim in the High Court. Inferior courts will charge less.