6 ms·
There have to be some Verizon or Yahoo employees on HN who are reading this. Can any of you shed some light on why Verizon and Yahoo aren't cooperating with th
by pmoriarty 7y ago
There have to be some Verizon or Yahoo employees on HN who are reading this.
Can any of you shed some light on why Verizon and Yahoo aren't cooperating with the Archive Team to archive this valuable historical content?
(If you don't feel comfortable commenting with your regular HN account, maybe you could do so with a throwaway account?)
Also, is it possible for any of you to bring this issue to the attention of upper management and help them understand how important it is to archive this?
You Verizon/Yahoo employees have much more power to make a difference here than anyone of us from the outside can.
- logicallee 7y agohow much storage do you think in total all of the Yahoo Groups content takes?
- geggam 7y agoOver 4 petabytes 8 years ago
- logicallee 7y agoOh.
- bflesch 7y agoI'd love to have this as a torrent
- logicallee 7y agoyou have 4,000 terabytes of storage space and bandwidth to torrent? (I'll be honest, I had to look up how many terabytes a petabyte is.)
- sgeisler 7y agoIt's actually not totally insane anymore. If you could afford a Tesla Roadster you can build yourself a 4PB storage solution. With some high density top loading storage servers (4HE for 90 HDDs), 6TB HDDs and some SSDs thrown in for caching you can build that in 36HE for less than 300k$ (not counting time needed to assemble and configure). So if that's your hobby, go ahead :D If one takes more than 5 minutes to research this I'm pretty sure that it's possible to push that number below 250k$.
- bflesch 7y agoYes, university should be able to make some room so researchers can work with it. It's a lot of data, but not impossible to do with a small investment.
- ygthrowaway 7y agoProbably not very helpful/informational but: I work for VzM, but not historically directly on Yahoo products (product teams have been merged/consolidated etc. over the past few years, but there's still strong tendencies toward products people came from). So I wouldn't be very clued into what's happening with Yahoo Groups internally. And I've heard nothing about this internally. At all. As it stands, it's 2:30pm in SV, VzM is top of the HN frontpage, and not a single soul has mentioned it yet on internal Slack. Will see if I can find out more.
- Diagon 7y agoThat could really help. Thank you!
- spsful 7y agoI hope this doesn't sound naive, but what does the M in VzM stand for?
- rkagerer 7y agoMaybe you could be the one to raise it on the Slack channel and (even better) get some eyeballs with authority clued in on the matter.
- notduncansmith 7y ago
- john_moscow 7y agoPure speculation, but if you publish something created by another person without an explicit permission by them, it may open you up for a lawsuit. If some groups required explicit approval by a moderator in order to read the posts, I would take it as they didn't want the content to go public. So technically, some legal troll could post some copyrighted information, wait for it to be published on Archive, and then sue Archive for copyright infringement and Verizon for assisting it. As a non-profit, Archive will likely get away with just taking it down, but a for-profit Verizon is a wholly different story.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoGroups can be private or not. Require approval, or not. The archiving team isn't attempting to break into private groups and archive them. Only public groups are going to be collected.
- jolmg 7y agoAlso, from one of the mails: > The 128 people you banned were REQUESTED by the group owners to get their stuff.
- user5994461 7y agoHere I wrote a blog post to explain why products are shutdown, illustrating Yahoo and Verizon. https://thehftguy.com/2019/12/10/why-products-are-shutdown-the-case-of-verizon-and-yahoo-groups/ https://thehftguy.com/2019/12/10/why-products-are-shutdown-t...
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoI think everyone understands that corporations don't want to spend money and effort maintaining servers that don't generate revenue. No one is really surprised that they won't help with archive efforts. The question is why they're spending real effort on blocking archivists. All they had to do was keep doing nothing for a few days. The cost to them might have been a couple hundred dollars' worth of bandwidth, at most, which I think archivists would have been happy to pay--they've done more before. (That's estimating based on small-scale commercial hosting prices; it might not even register on whatever enterprise uplink Yahoo/Verizon uses.) Instead they've got at least one professional taking time away from productive work to fuck with archivists at no benefit to anyone. It's possible that the wage-hours spent on this actually exceed what the bandwidth costs would have been. It's astonishingly petty.
- cr0sh 7y ago<conspiracy tinfoil hat> Is it possible that there may be some kind of political angle to all of this; that archiving this information for the future might allow someone to find out something that someone else doesn't want to come to light? </conspiracy tinfoil hat>
- user5994461 7y agoTwo reasons I can think of right away. There can have a policy (and people) to detect abuse and shut off bot accounts, this can even be a separate entity from Yahoo Groups. Second, there can be internal metrics tracking active users and viewed pages, to get down as low as possible before deletion. In both cases archive.org is ruining it for them.