2 ms·
This assumes you have the ideal database schema with the ideal data content producers with the ideal user. One could call into question any of the assumptions
by phendrenad2 7y ago
This assumes you have the ideal database schema with the ideal data content producers with the ideal user.
One could call into question any of the assumptions here, so why not go straight for the most self-assured one:
"I never ever ever want to jump to page 317 right from the beginning. There’s absolutely no use case out there, where I search for something, and then I say, hey, I believe my search result will be item #3175 in the current sort order."
...Unless you're trying to save money by shopping for some common item on eBay or Amazon, in which case your search will yield 1000s of results with the same name and slightly different prices, and no way to tell when the next level of "quality" begins. For instance, the first 3 pages of results may be some accessory for the item you really want, priced at $1. Then thankfully on page 4, you find the cheapest version of the item you're looking for. Pages 5-55 are all that exact item, plus accessory packs for a more expensive iteration of the item. Finally on page 56, you find the next step up in quality of the item, you decide it's sufficient for your purposes, and you purchase it.
Now wouldn't jumping directly to page 50 and then page 100 help you narrow down your search?
Now tell me how filtering or infinite scroll can aid in this situation. It can't. The only thing that can fix it is better control on eBay's part to weed out duplicate listings, but that would involve some pretty hefty machine learning, and suddenly eBa would have to raise their rates massively, and I'd no longer buy from there.
- jlokier 7y agoThis is the #1 reason I don't use Ebay much any more. When searching on Ebay, I use a sort of binary search on page numbers. The algorithm goes like this: - Set number of results per page to the maximum allowed, 200. - Scroll through results on page 1. Item I searched isn't found? - Scroll through results on page 5. Item I searched isn't found? - Scroll through results on page 20. Item I search is found? - Scroll through results on page 10. Item I searched isn't found? - Scroll through results on page 12. Item I searched isn't found? - Scroll through results on page 15. Item I searched is found about half way down? - Scroll through results on page 14. Item I searched is found about half way down? - Scroll through results on page 13. Item I searched is found about half way down but it's spares & repair only? - Ok, I can begin *really* browsing what I'm looking for from half way down page 14, and expect the density to increase with each page. The process is restarted with each new search query, so it takes quite a long time to hunt for things worth buying if I haven't decided exactly what I want, and that's why I don't buy much from Ebay any more. But if I had to infinite-scroll to get to the first useful result at item #2800, for each search, it would take so much longer. I'm pretty sure Ebay could improve this UX by segmenting search results.