Huh, I stand corrected. My original complaint still applies to >99% of criticality studies, but the field might be coming around since the last time I looked in

Huh, I stand corrected. My original complaint still applies to >99% of criticality studies, but the field might be coming around since the last time I looked into it, 3 years ago. Skimming through the papers, I'm still skeptical of how stringent a test their 'exponent relation' really is, but it's an improvement.