4 ms·
> SNCF is something like $45 Billion in debt? The state owns and controls the SNCF, its expenses, subsidies and pricing. Its debt is meaningless, in that the g
by einpoklum 7y ago
> SNCF is something like $45 Billion in debt?
The state owns and controls the SNCF, its expenses, subsidies and pricing. Its debt is meaningless, in that the government decides how much in debt it is in.
> can retire using last 6 months of wages (vs avg wages)?
Retiring based on the status and position you've reached is common in many workplaces/industries, in many countries.
> They are guaranteed a job for life?
Nobody is guaranteed a job for life. If you mean to say, that if they do their job, the company can't fire them, then I don't see a problem with that.
> They get free / low cost housing?
They don't get free houses. Maybe they get free accommodations if their shifts take them far away from home; which would be reasonable.
> They get 28 regular paid days off an maybe another 22 or so RTT days?
Read about RTT days here:
https://www.e-days.com/news/france-in-focus-understanding-different-countries-annual-leave https://www.e-days.com/news/france-in-focus-understanding-di...
this is not special to railway conductors. The fact that in other countries people are being worked to the bone is the problem, not the fact that in France they aren't.
Also, RTT is a means to decrease unemployment by spreading work among more people. Saying it's excessive means essentially "let's pay the same thing to less people for more work".
Yes, the conditions are not bad; and people in the US should be inspired to organize, unionize - and not in those yellow collaborationist unions in the AFL-CIO, but in independent unions or in an IWW section, and demand decent, French-level employment conditions, at least.
- privateSFacct 7y ago> The state owns and controls the SNCF, its expenses, subsidies and pricing. Its debt is meaningless, in that the government decides how much in debt it is in. The debt is a sign of the amount of additional subsidy needed to cover the benefits / expenses being paid. This amount (largish for France) will need to be paid by taxpayers. It is not meaningless. > Retiring based on the status and position you've reached is common in many workplaces/industries, in many countries. The french system normally pays based on a 25 year average pay (inflation adjusted)?Using most recent (highest paid) 6 months is not the same or standard. Can you name any other country that uses this method? Short periods like this are also prone to manipulation. > If you mean to say, that if they do their job, the company can't fire them, then I don't see a problem with that. The prohibition on layoffs consecutive to economic difficulties or technological changes is one of the benefits of the railway job - I'm just pointing that out. Other jobs even in france allows dismissal for economic reasons (if you offer employee modified job etc etc).
- throwaway73629 7y ago> The french system normally pays based on a 25 year average pay (inflation adjusted)?Using most recent (highest paid) 6 months is not the same or standard. I’m not sure “normally” is the right word here. The system in France is rather complicated. SNCF workers aren’t the only ones whose pension uses the last six months of income to determine the amount of the pension payment. Under the current system: Private sector salaried workers receive one pension where the calculation is based on their highest earning 25 years (adjusted for inflation). The calculation also takes into account the number of years worked in the private salaried worker sector. These workers may, depending on their job, also receive a second pension where the amount received is based on total points earned over all years worked (AGIRC - ARRCO). Public sector workers receive a pension where the calculation is based on their last six months of earnings, as well as the number of years they worked in the public sector. Self-employed workers pay into yet a number of different systems. I’m not familiar with all them, but many are based on total points earned over the years of contribution. Finally, it’s possible for someone who’s worked at different times as a private salaried worker, a public sector worker, and a self-employed worker, to collect pensions from all the different sources.
- TulliusCicero 7y ago> Retiring based on the status and position you've reached is common in many workplaces/industries, in many countries. It's silly everywhere it exists. Why should a last year promotion change your retirement income so much?
- privateSFacct 7y agoMost places average over at least 3 years. If you do a shorter period it's not uncommon for folks to pension spike. Do cash-outs / do bonuses for each other or temporary / activing director of positions that are empty but very high paying. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_spiking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_spiking The french system may prohibit these kind of raises and promotions in the last year of employment.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoThat's still dumb though. Why should it be anything other than averaging over your whole career? What makes the last few years super special?
- einpoklum 7y agoIt's all "dumb". Why should a manager or an engineer get a higher salary than a warehouse employee who works his ass off all day? Why should younger workers get lower salaries than older workers just because they have less seniority? One could argue that it should be the other way around, since the younger ones are not established yet and have a lot more expenses. The logic is that you retire with a pension corresponding to the level you've reached as an employee. It's not more or less dumb than averaging.