6 ms·
I am in general a big fan of GCP, especially for startups. In many cases I find I can be productive faster in GCP compared to AWS, in the sense that it's easier
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I am in general a big fan of GCP, especially for startups. In many cases I find I can be productive faster in GCP compared to AWS, in the sense that it's easier to do "wrong" things in AWS if you don't have a top notch devops person.
That said, it seems like GCP has a real, significant problem with overall reliability. While I don't have numbers to compare, seems like I see frequent outage notifications on HN for GCP. They really need to focus more on reliability than new features.
- RKearney 7y ago> I am in general a big fan of GCP, especially for startups. The major disagreement here from me on this is that GCP does not support IPv6 (outside of IPv6 termination on load balancers) and I do not agree with startups launching without IPv6 support in 2019.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoAs a network person thank you for bootstrapping IPv6 where you can. Most folks still don’t care :-(.
- eloff 7y agoI agree it's important, but it doesn't really bother me since I'll put Cloudflare and or a network load balancer in front of anything external facing anyway. Internal things being ipv4 is fine. Other benefits aside you halve your bandwidth bill by putting Cloudflare in front.
- ljhsiung 7y agoIn case you're curious, here's some logs about their status https://status.cloud.google.com/summary https://status.cloud.google.com/summary Looking at Cloud Compute, the one responsible for the outage today and I think the big one a few months ago (13 hours!!!), they still do achieve 99% uptime (having been down 81 hours total this year). While 99% uptime "sounds" great, this is paltry in comparison to AWS, which has set the standard for 99.99% (also known as "4 9s") in reliability, translating to about an hour of downtime per year. Just gives you some more perspective and concrete numbers. Perhaps one of the reasons you find GCP "faster" is due to more devotion of resources to "speed" over "reliability".
- lostmyoldone 7y agoWhere is AWS logs for all service outages, partial or not? Can't seem to find them, only "selected" outages. The recent, several hours long, service degradation in Frankfurt EC2 isn't in the historical list, seems like it is only in the rolling status history? AWS and GCloud seem to also be reporting disruptions completely differently, AWS reports on tons of smaller pieces which makes any "aggregate" uptime become something completely different than if you report on larger aggregates as GCloud seems to do. Unless I'm missing something, I don't see how one could compare comparing service availability reasonably without running large numbers of "canary" instances on both providers to actually measure aggregate availability?
- jordanthoms 7y agoI don't think you can judge uptime for either AWS or GCP from the status pages, both of them are slow to update their pages when issues start and plenty of less major issues (which could still bring down a individual customer) never make the status page at all.
- blaisio 7y agoI agree that they seem to have problems more frequently than AWS. I've been told it is frequently due to their network, which is incredibly advanced and efficient but also incredibly complex and therefore more easily broken.