11 ms·
This was the moment that Sony could have made something useful out of themselves here for allowing Linux to be used on a popular games console at the time, as i
by rvz 7y ago
This was the moment that Sony could have made something useful out of themselves here for allowing Linux to be used on a popular games console at the time, as in improving the accessibility of installing Linux on a computing machine. (Or even basing GameOS on Linux).
Instead they cowardly remove it due to a 'hack' by Geohot and locked it down for 'security purposes' and potential researchers, scientists and those without access to supercomputers are the ones to suffer from this decision.
Sony had to appeal to their gaming community over the science community so that's that.
Also it's 'OtherOS' not 'OpenOS'.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoTo play the devil's advocate, Sony is in the business of selling games, their cosnoles were just a means to that and since they were selling the hardware at a loss, selling more of it to people who will never buy games was bad for their business model.
- ascagnel_ 7y agoThere was no reason they couldn’t have sold a slightly less locked-down system to researchers at a higher price point —- Microsoft did exactly that with unsold X360 Kinect units (and bundled in a USB adapter) for medical research.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoThe reason was cost. Have fun convincing management to allocate resources to develop and support another SKU tailored for researchers.
- mschuster91 7y agoSo what? Don't need much difference in hardware, it was only a firmware change.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoFirmware changes that relax the security of your hardware require a lot of red tape and raise much fear in management. SONY is infamous for going overboard on DRM.
- LaserToy 7y agoIt is time and not a priority. A lot of things can be done given unlimited time and resources, but unfortunately we don’t have that.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoYou don't need to - just license it out to a third-party systems integrator.
- zyztem 7y agoCell processor shipped for commercial installation in the IBM Blades QS20/QS21/QS22, which was based on Roadrunner supercomputer. Sony also demoed rack-mount with Cell (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zego https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zego) but it is not clear that it was available in open market
- leggomylibro 7y agoDidn't they sell a bunch of PS3s to the US Air Force for research purposes? I'm sure that military personnel enjoy games as much as the next person, but it's probably not why they bought the machines. https://phys.org/news/2010-12-air-playstation-3s-supercomputer.html https://phys.org/news/2010-12-air-playstation-3s-supercomput...
- kube-system 7y agoThey did. The article linked above mentions that it took them a while to convince Sony to agree to it. Also, if you run the math in the article you linked, it may suggest they paid more than list price. > core made of 1,760 Sony PlayStation 3 (PS3) consoles > the PS3s for the supercomputer's core cost about $2 million that's $1,136 per unit.
- ianai 7y agoDefinitely a completely different support contract than a consumer console. That sounds more like an amortization of how many consoles they’d need to support that large of a system for the life of the contract.
- lozaning 7y agoCould also be the rake you pay to the company who will sell you hardware on terms with a PO. Company I worked for in the past had a significant line of business with a major post prod company in the valley that was just buying hundreds of DVD players off ebay at a 20% mark up and then drop shipping them. There's tons of companies and government agencies that cant just send someone to bestbuy with a visa to make purchases. Has to be a preapproved vendor and has to be on at least net 30 terms and purchased via PO. There's a premium to be paid to companies/vendors that can work within your companies processes to quickly get you what you need to not block projects. I do wonder if PS3 have GSA pricing though.
- zanny 7y agoTo play devils advocate, you can sell games without building perfectly viable general purpose compute hardware and then locking it down with DRM to make it useless as such. Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo are not developing game consoles out of anything but an incredibly evil greed - they are wasting insurmountable amounts of raw materials making computers that cannot be used as computers. The consoles that existed in the 70s and 80s were largely justified in being specialized hardware specifically for realtime rendering which had no realistic application outside the narrow scope of fixed function realtime interactive rendering they produced. In the 90s the PS1, N64, and Dreamcast were all computer adjacent with the next geration - PS2 / Gamecube / Xbox - all being perfectly functional general purpose computers that were simply crippled with proprietary software into being toys. Since then their hardware has only gotten more generic and general purpose and the degree of their draconian platform lockdown grown to an insane degree to resist emulation and unlocking. Its a shame Valve only ever saw SteamOS as a hedge against Microsoft - if they had taken it seriously and put in the legitimate ridiculous amount of money it would have taken to breakout a console platform without the horrifying amount of proprietary bullshit going into the competitions products we might have seen that incredible amount of waste become as taboo as it deserves to be. Honestly the worst offender is the Nintendo Switch - it is verbatim just the successor device to the Nvidia Shield Tablet, just with a grotesque proprietary operating environment and impenetrably locked bootloader. Every time I see one of those things I am struck by how absurdly wasteful it is to see someone carrying that thing and a regular tablet when Nintendo, Sony, and Microsoft could all just be shipping their own proprietary DRM laden store apps on top of a freedom respecting software foundation. If you want to exploit people by depriving software freedoms while they pay you for it... I'd argue its a product of propagandized deception and manipulation, but its still people considered informed consumers buying that garbage. Its a lot less bad than entire computers, fit for a multitude of purposes, being reduced to toys.
- Nition 7y ago> Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo are not developing game consoles out of anything but an incredibly evil greed - they are wasting insurmountable amounts of raw materials making computers that cannot be used as computers. I think this is a bit harsh. Is artwork a waste of good canvas? (I guess to be fair to you here, at least canvas is a renewable resource)
- kevingadd 7y agoPlus they eventually got dinged for this because they had inexplicably advertised the Linux support, so removing it turned that into false advertising. Owners of the classic PS3 got a chunk of $ from a class action settlement.
- scarface74 7y agoCorrection: the lawyers got a chunk of money....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- MrMember 7y agoI'll never buy another Sony console again after they removed the ability to run Linux on the PS3. It's one of the reasons I bought one and I used it a lot.
- grogenaut 7y agoDo you buy Microsoft or Nintendo consoles? If so why?
- lostgame 7y agoI buy Nintendo consoles due to the quality of the software and hardware. The Nintendo DS, at the time, was unparalleled in terms of software quality, and, while not as portable as a Game Boy Advance, was compatible with my existing GBA collection, allowed me to wirelessly play; and even eventually play online, with friends, and offered an almost dauntingly large library of quality software. This was before the days of the iPhone, and while I did have a Windows Phone at the time, it never could have, and certainly did not, have the library of software, or hardware design, to consider it a valid console. Being a PDA and a phone was more than enough at the time. I played ‘Halo’, of all things, on my PowerBook G4 back in the day, saw that as the driver to XBOX, and couldn’t have cared less.
- grogenaut 7y agoBut both of these companies are hostile to Linux... Why would you buy anything from them? Is it worse to try and fail than to never try at all?
- scarface74 7y agoDo you think that Sony is having executive board meetings worrying about a few Linux users who won’t buy their consoles?
- qxnqd 7y agoYes, they share the room with the Facebook executives who worry about the HN users who will quit the social network.
- grogenaut 7y ago(I'm sure I'll lose karma for explaining Sonys side, since some people just want to be mad) Linux support was not removed due to Geohot. It was a driver and business priority issue. Geohot just sealed the deal. Having worked there during the kerfuffle, I can confirm their reason was valid for not supporting Linux going forward. It was a non trivial effort and they wanted those engineers to make it support the new hardware turns. It was a company wide goal to hit break even at retail pricing at that time (Sony was amazing at running hardware coat forecasting internally and iirc hit their 7 year Target by a week). This required the new hardware. So they dropped Linux. That part is real. Then they effed up by not messaging it well and by dropping promised back support. And then a bunch of the community responded as petulant children and attacked sonys main business and released products that allowed others to infringe Sony and other game studios property with impunity. These actions killed any chance Sony would engage with this community for the next decade or so. Sony was also backed into a corner technically as I recall as the thing hot hacked (by realizing it was a null crypto key on the one processor), and thus allowed Linux was also the thing that did the drm. Sony had to choose between another year or so of drm or Linux support. As in many cases not parties are at fault. Contracts can and are broken. Sony paid multiple prices for it. So did the Linux/hacker community.
- Jasper_ 7y agoMy recollection is that the PS3/Linux thing was a failed tax dodge, because that meant you could classify the system as a general purpose computer instead of a game console. When the EU decided to categorize it as a game console anyway, they killed the Linux project.
- IronBacon 7y agoWasn't that the PS2? I recall they offered a "Linux" kit with mouse/keyboard, network/HDD adapter (so limited for fat models only) and a VGA cable to use with a computer monitor with sync-on-green support...
- vvanders 7y agoYeah, that sounds about right. As someone who was on the dev side of the fence at that time one of the areas where Sony was pretty poor was the devtools. Other than some hardware capabilities of the profiler Microsoft blew away everything else that Sony had. While running Linux on it was pretty neat, I wonder what the opportunity cost was to other parts of the development experience on the platform.
- DCKing 7y agoThis doesn't take anything away from Sony's decision making, but removing OtherOS never really helped them "get good security". The PlayStation 3 was cracked wide open [1] without OtherOS and because people were pissed at its removal. On Playstation 3s released in the first 3.5 years of its lifespan you can get full hypervisor compromise without any hardware mods, and you can yet again run OtherOS on the latest firmware. Now with less restrictions than before. Newer PS3s (starting with CECH-25xx) have 'only' been partially compromised. They can't run OtherOS, but they can still run homebrew and piracy despite Sony taking OtherOS away. Maybe it's a bit of solace that this stuff only punished Sony. But inevitably, the lesson they learnt is "we'll never experiment with this stuff again". [1]: This video is really worth watching if you're interested in this stuff: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUGGJpn2_zY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUGGJpn2_zY
- ScottFree 7y ago> due to a 'hack' by Geohot This is OT, but I think people here might enjoy it: Geohot doing hackerrank problems for 5 hours straight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EecfVsdQMcM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EecfVsdQMcM
- matheusmoreira 7y agoIt was never about supporting Linux or scientific computing. They just wanted to pay less taxes. Linux support is what allowed them to argue the PS2 and PS3 were real computers rather than just an entertainment product.