2 ms·
> but the fact that access to healthcare _EVER_ factors in to your career is manifestly wrong. ABSOLUTELY. I should be able to independently choose my healthca
by paulddraper 7y ago
> but the fact that access to healthcare _EVER_ factors in to your career is manifestly wrong.
ABSOLUTELY. I should be able to independently choose my healthcare coverage. I purchase my home/renters insurance, my car insurance, my liability insurance, my life insurance, etc. separately from my employer. Why not health insurance???
Employer-tied health insurance is literally federal law in the U.S.
It still boggles my mind how widely supported the ACA employer mandate ("Obamacare") was by my fellow Americans.
And disappoints me that the mandate wasn't repealed in 2017-2018 when it appeared the right politicians were in place.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 7y agoThe widely supported aspects of the ACA were guaranteed issue and the elimination of low quality plans (which really were pretty useless as insurance). Those things cost a lot of money and forcing employers to pay into the system (think of the mandate as a tax) is one of the ways they were paid for. It's fine to not like it, but it was probably one of the less disruptive options for collecting more health care dollars. As far as I can figure, there's really only 2 paths forward for the US system. Dump more money into it or train lots more providers. People don't seem to think we are short on doctors, but the market looks sort of exactly supply constrained, where everyone is busy and prices go up up up. Of course, because we are stupid, some of the most significant healthcare regulations...limit supply.
- paulddraper 7y ago> think of the mandate as a tax It's not a tax though. It's finding, choosing, paying for a particular insurance plan for their employees. Thus, insurance being tied to employment.
- maxerickson 7y agoOkay, I didn't really address that. I would argue that it didn't change the situation that much, because the situation prior to the ACA was that being in a group plan (employer coverage) was the best way for people with significant medical needs to maintain insurance. For many people, "A good job" has long been one that came with health coverage (and given the expense of insurance, this continues to be the case). It would be excellent for us to have a situation where people bought their health insurance individually. I think requiring more employers to provide insurance probably was an incremental step in that direction, as counter intuitive as it is, because it addressed the situation that existed in an achievable way.