3 ms·
I think this is an excellent point. I really agree with pg's thesis, but I think it would be worthwhile for him to go more in depth into the "edge cases" he tal
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I think this is an excellent point. I really agree with pg's thesis, but I think it would be worthwhile for him to go more in depth into the "edge cases" he talks about in passing, mainly because I think these edge cases actually bolster his thesis, not detract from it.
Companies like Theranos and WeWork succeeded for a short while because they tried to "hack the test". E.g. Theranos hacked the metrics of "buzz", "investment amount", "notable people on your board", but they didn't actually have a working product. Adam Neumann certainly "hacked the test" to the tune of a billion plus dollars, but WeWork certainly didn't succeed (I'd note there is still a critical difference between Theranos and WeWork in that customers actually really like the product WeWork provides, the question is just can they provide it profitably).
I think hacking the test can get you so far in the startup world, but eventually reality rears its head and what matters is whether you can provide a product people want, profitability.
One quick note on your cigarettes example. The problem here is that companies are giving people what they want, they've just figured out how to "hack the test" so to speak with respect to what the human body wants. This is basically the case with all addictive substances - there is essentially a hackable part of the human "desire" subsystem that people have taken advantage of.
- watwut 7y agoTheranos issue was not lack of product. Their problem was massive fraud going effectively demanded from top levels. Framing it as lack of product is unfair to all startups who lacked good product, hacked buzz, got investment, got notable people and then did not committed fraud. Plus it suggests that Theranos fraud is result of not having product. The same people would be engaging in unethical conduct with product too.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoDisagree. "Not having product", when you say you DO have product, and are very specific about the capabilities of said non-existent product, is the actual definition of fraud.
- watwut 7y agoIt is possible to not have product and be vague and get investment and keep going before crashing. Plus, Theranos fraud was waaay more bigger then that.
- killerstorm 7y agoWhat's about homeopathy? It is advertised to have medical benefits, presumably has none, and is a multi-billion business, with many companies which exist for decades and decades. For any non-trivial product there's information asymmetry problem, so pretty much everything is hackable, but to different extents.