4 ms·
>Placing the head of Google, which contributes more than 99% of Alphabet’s sales, at the helm of it could call into question the entire purpose of Alphabet I t
by tim333 7y ago
>Placing the head of Google, which contributes more than 99% of Alphabet’s sales, at the helm of it could call into question the entire purpose of Alphabet
I think this gives a false impression of the value of the non Google bits of Alphabet
Currently the market cap of Alphabet is $924bn and "Waymo is worth about $105 billion" (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-27/waymo-valuation-slashed-on-autonomous-vehicle-tech-delays https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-27/waymo-val...)
which would make that 11% of the valuation and probably other bits of other bets are worth something too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- endorphone 7y agoThe market cap of Waymo is $0 because it has no market cap. [edit: note that the parent comment originally spoke to the `market cap' of Waymo before an edit, giving context to this reply] An analyst independently made up a number, likely to justify an outsized Google target number. There have been rumors that Google will seek outside investments in Waymo that might legitimize some valuation, but they haven't. And for now Waymo's revenue is estimated to be $5M. While Google's revenue is about $160,000M. So I don't think they're giving a false impression of anything. Google has been pouring enormous sums of Adword cash into Waymo and it's still a stuttering business ten years later.
- drawkbox 7y agoWaymo is in the value creation phase, business/marketing/analysts may not value it as much but there is a goldmine under it. Waymo may not be a revenue behemoth currently but there is immense value there not only to self-driving but to maps improvement and more. I am not a fan of software patents but they have surpassed Toyota in patents [1] and there are hundreds of patents from Waymo [2]. Everyday in Arizona Waymo vehicles you see them on every block. The value extractors may not like not being able to extract value yet, but the product, research and value creation is very high and contributes today to improving Google product offerings outside of Waymo such as Maps [3]. Waymo has waymo value than is being extracted because it is still emerging from the product value creation nebula that business/marketing/analysts can't see and don't value as much as product/engineering/creative people. [1] https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Business-trends/Google-s-Waymo-unseats-Toyota-as-automated-driving-patent-king https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Business-trends/Google-s-Wa... [2] https://patents.justia.com/assignee/waymo-llc https://patents.justia.com/assignee/waymo-llc [3] https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2019-10-09/waymo-mapping-los-angeles-driverless-taxis https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2019-10-09/waymo-mapp...
- bayarrhea 7y agoThat’s a long way of saying Waymo isn’t making any money.
- drawkbox 7y agoMoney making products don't start making efficient money day one. Value creation in this area takes time and it is not quick when dealing with physical/driving products. The patents alone will probably be worth more than the effort. Google is a data/information company and you are completely disregarding the impact Waymo has on that especially for the Maps product. Waymo is also already a market leader in their space. Just because it isn't registering big enough revenues to McKinsey level value extraction only MBAs like CEO Sundar Pichai and Wall Street doesn't mean anything. Most of those in that space have no idea how to create value, only extract it. This type of 'it isn't making money' thinking is similar to how Jeff Bezos at Amazon was attacked for putting all profits back into R&D, or how Elon Musk at Tesla/SpaceX pushes products, or even when Jobs came back to Apple. The bean counters do not understand value creation and do not have product/engineering/creative mindsets. What product/engineering/creative people do is value creation that create the engines for 'making money', the engine doesn't just pop in, there is a concerted effort of play, production, design, creativity, engineering, crafting and refinement that takes value creation to get that engine running which results in value extraction. The business/marketing/managers should just stay out of the engine room and just make sure there is enough runway. The product before the sales/marketing is key. A product of value can always be sold or marketed. You can't sell/market your way to a product.
- scarface74 7y agoAmazon retail is still a low margin, low profit business and is not a good example. AWS on the other hand is printing money. Google hasn’t had a non advertising based hit besides maybe Android since it’s inception and even that has only made $23 billion a year in profit from its inception until the Oracle trial where the number was revealed.
- 7y ago
- dylan604 7y ago>And for now Waymo's revenue is estimated to be $5M. While Google's revenue is about $160,000M. Why the decision to write $160,000M vs $160B? Was it so the same as the previous $5M number? Even still, it seems unnatural to me.
- topkai22 7y agoI think it’s a good practice to keep the abbreviations the same when talking about in the same context. It makes clear the ratio being talked about.
- dylan604 7y agoI'm definitely not in the world of finance, but in day to day conversation, I have to stop to think what one hundred sixty thousand million means. If I hear one hundred sixty billion, then I immediately understand. Even if I had previously heard five million then heard one hundred sixty billion, it is obvious that billion is 1000x a million which clearly makes it a bigger number. This is what I meant by unnatural.
- topkai22 7y agoVerbal conversation gains the context of audible emphasis on the difference. Rhetorically, you are able to say "Waymo has revenue of 5 million dollars, while Google has 160 BILLION dollars." (imagine the all caps being dramatically stated, possibly a la Dr Evil in Austin Powers). In writing you can't do that as easily or effectively, so I think keeping the abbreviated units the same is effective writing. In fact stating income in thousand millions is exactly how financial statements are formatted. In alphabet's 10k (at https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000165204419000004/goog10-kq42018.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000165204419...) there is a table showing that the google segment had $136,224M in revenue, while "all other bets" had a total revenue of $595M. I suspect that the SEC would have some stern words for alphabet if they expressed on measure in billions and one in millions...
- sowbug 7y agoAs topkai22 said, it's to make the author's comparison easy to understand. But this is a chance to mention that ~50 years ago the UK abandoned its old "billion" terminology, which used to be equivalent to a trillion elsewhere (10^12), and adopted the global definition of "billion" as 10^9. I think they called 10^9 a milliard, but I've never seen it in use. For a long time after the change, you'd see English written for an international audience using a more drawn-out version of large numbers (a "million million" for example) sort of the same way we have metric next to imperial these days. That's not what's happening here, but it's interesting.
- ukyrgf 7y agoThis isn't an insightful comment, but I just said out loud "what's Waymo again?" after having seen the name here and there for the past decade. Kinda feels dead on arrival.
- mav3rick 7y agoJust because you didn't like the name ? They have the least disengagements and more miles than anyone (with a LIDAR).