2 ms·
> If you merely read good books on medieval history, most of the stuff you learned wouldn't be on the test. It's not good books you want to read, but the lectur
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> If you merely read good books on medieval history, most of the stuff you learned wouldn't be on the test. It's not good books you want to read, but the lecture notes and assigned reading in this class.
It is the professor's job to decide which parts of medieval history are the most important to learn. Therefore, those are what I need to study.
Maybe not all professors do this effectively—but as long as we're talking about ideals, this is how it should work.
- thepete2 7y ago> And even most of that you can ignore, because you only have to worry about the sort of thing that could turn up as a test question.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThat part just did not describe my experience in college. Maybe I was bad at knowing what "could turn up as a test question." My college also did not have any old tests floating around, at least as far as I was aware.
- fhennig 7y agoI think we should just drop book work questions altogether and allow students to take notes into the exam. Just make the tests about analysis and synthesis, which is the stuff you should be able to do if you truly understood something and didn't just memorize some facts.
- watwut 7y agoIn classes I have seen, things you could ignore were minority of it and usually side stuff like funny anecdotes, minor players that are there for you to get feel for the context, famous nun dick tree and such. This stuff helps you learn important stuff and makes it all less dry, but it absolutely does not make sense to penalize students for not learning it actively.
- watwut 7y agoYeah, this came across to me as overly simplistic not really thought out argument too. I dont think that college medieval history not being the "students can pick any part of it and anything you learn about medieval history is good to go" is some kind of massive issue with medieval history course. It does not mean that you did not learned or that grade does not measure learning. It just means the topic is not whole medieval history (which would be ridiculously broad) but only selected parts of it. It is kind of like complaining that algorithms 101 are allowing students to pick any algorithms to learn and require everyone to learn the same set of algorithms.
- bonoboTP 7y agoRight, I had a similar reaction. Autodidacts often end up reading a bunch of stuff from here and there with sub-par results. One of the main benefits of a (university) course is focus and guidance. That the prof or teacher selects specific topics they deem important for that stage of education. As a student it can be difficult to judge that yourself.