4 ms·
What most sites call a "password" is really just a cached email challenge. Tweak this so it generates a new token on every challenge, and it's actually pretty s
by mindslight 7y ago
What most sites call a "password" is really just a cached email challenge. Tweak this so it generates a new token on every challenge, and it's actually pretty slick. If the service is compromised such that the userdb is copied, they can just wipe the whole cache.
The biggest sin here is inventing a new method, requiring actual analysis of its properties. The indignation from the cargo cult is a bonus though. Most of the upset is probably from people being prevented from setting their password to the same one they use on every other site.
- danShumway 7y agoMedium already got rid of passwords and uses email tokens for all logins. It's really annoying as an end user, but it does work. Assuming they're not a troll, I think their sin is trying to reinvent a method that already existed, and reinventing it poorly.