3 ms·
Awesome! Let's get down to some nuance! Flight: Rail is awesome! BUT they aren't in place. Besides that, they require a lot of steel and energy. Both of which
by godelski 7y ago
Awesome! Let's get down to some nuance!
Flight: Rail is awesome! BUT they aren't in place. Besides that, they require a lot of steel and energy. Both of which are highly carbon intensive problems. Will they reduce the carbon load in total? Probably. Meaningfully? Probably not.
Shipping: Alcohol, biodiesel, pelletised solid fuels like wood scraps, etc are not carbon neutral. Sure, they are less than diesel and we should take steps forward even if they are small, but the issue is that we don't have any idea of a real alternative that can scale.
Heat and A/C: humidity and moisture control is literally the C in A/C. I'd challenge you to look into all the technologies listed under the wiki you linked. None are carbon neutral. I'll count concentrated solar as close enough. The issue here is that it doesn't scale well. Plus, we need both heating and cooling.
Industry: I'm going to ignore this because I think we agree and yeah, it is highly convoluted and hard to get into in this discussion. Is this okay? (it is 21% though [0])
Concrete/Steel/Construction: Your alternatives are all carbon intensive. I'm not sure what your argument is here. I apologize, but it feels like you are suggesting that old methods equates to less carbon intensive methods. And can we just put this myth to rest? Wood is carbon neutral, at best! But there's a big reason we don't use wood a lot. You can't build sky scrapers with them. (There's a long discussion here about how actually concentration of populations decreases emissions because it radically reduces logistics costs, but that is also highly convoluted and deserves several posts on its own).
Agriculture: I'm surprised you didn't say it, but the best alternative here is gene editing. You're also acting like agriculture isn't 25% of emissions[0]. The biggest issue here is a growing population. Just like fertilizer was one of the most important discoveries in human history (please read the history here), the next thing that allows us to get to 10bn people (my guess is gene editing) will be equally as important. But we need to look at low emission options, let along realize people have emission problems on their own (we're not Hitler and not just going to kill everyone. We aren't Mao and going to limit populations (like we can, HA!)
Heating/cooling: I combined this above. See above. There is no low-hanging fruit. Please provide reference on this.
You reference Smil, but I'm talking about issues he himself is concerned about. He is highly concerned with iron (and steel), cement, and plastics. He is very aware that we don't have great alternatives. It is rather distasteful to reference someone so skeptical of advancement while claiming that we're rather close to solving the problem. Smil is highly skeptical. Quoting him: "I have never been wrong on these major energy and environmental issues because I have nothing to sell."[1] If you're going to quote someone, for the love of god, don't quote someone that is counter to your position.
[0] https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emissions-data https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emiss...
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20180322234243/http://science.sciencemag.org/content/359/6382/1320.full https://web.archive.org/web/20180322234243/http://science.sc...
- dredmorbius 7y agoWe're more in agreement than disagreement. And I'm largely not contesting your assertion that these are challenges. The question is what, if any, alternatives or mitigations are available. I don't think we're close to solving the problems. But there are domains which look more promising. We can at least look to exploiting those (which means spreading awareness), whilst addressing others, and cutting a huge intractable problem into smaller ... yes, still often only very-barely tractable ... problems. You might care to adopt a less confrontational attitude. There's also the distinction between remaing at the present level of ~37 gigatons CO2 (increasing at 1.6% per year, or doubling every 43 years), to far nearer 0 in terms of gross, and what potential there is for then making up that difference. My preferred carbon capture technologies are wetlands and trees, in about that order, for the record. On rail: of transport modes, only water is more efficient, and that just. Before rail, canal or river conveyance was your best bet, and that still carries tremendous amounts of cargo, with high bandwidth but low latency. All told, the embedded energy of rail is comparatively low, especially relative to paved roads (asphalt). It's pretty hard to do better. Let's not toss this one out. Shipping: again, it's not carbon-neutral, but the most effective use of what carbon we're using, with mitigations elsewhere, if possible. The point being that there is far more fuel flexibility than in flight. Indoor climate control: Again, the question remains, what's possible. Passive designs, which in many cases aren't high-tech, but traditional, can achieve. At the very least, directly addressing heating and cooling via passive, thermal storage, and circulation methods makes the remaining humidity / moisture concerns more tractable. Materials: The larger point here is that changing costs (financial, internalised ecological, energy) will change materials and land use, and building practices. Skyscrapers are ... useful in some regards, but with light to increasing urban densities, there's a lot of mileage in low-rise construction (5-10 storeys), which traditional materials are well capable of, and which achieve densities that only a very few high-rise cities presently match. Ag: numbers I have say 13% of total emissions: https://www.wri.org/blog/2014/05/everything-you-need-know-about-agricultural-emissions https://www.wri.org/blog/2014/05/everything-you-need-know-ab... A large fraction of which is livestock (I'd listed nitrogen fertiliser, which I still believe is the largest fossil fuel input). Thankfully, methane's residency in the atmosphere is far shorter than CO2's, though it's a much more powerful greenhouse gas. Global livestock biomass is truly immense, both absolutely and by historical standards: http://peakoilbarrel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Terrestrial-Vertebrate-Biomass.jpg http://peakoilbarrel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Terrestr... https://xkcd.com/1338/ https://xkcd.com/1338/ Genetic engineering of crops may be possible, but we've already transferred a great deal of agricultural primary productivity from survival to caloric activity through the Green Revolution and hybridisation. How much potential remains is ... an interesting question. (See especially Ophuls's ecology texts.) For heating/cooling, the low-hanging fruit are passive designs, additional insulation, thermal mass, site-appropriate design, limited footprint, limited exposure, increased ventilation in warmer climates especially, as well as district heating / cooling. These can achieve tremendous efficiencies over existing heating/cooling loads. Again, reading to point: the solvable portion of the problem makes the less-solvable moisture/humidity management at least more tractable. Smil: He'll be the first to tell you that he doesn't have all the answers, and that BAU isn't sustainable. But he'll do so with copious amounts of extensively-researched, detailed, and soberly-presented facts, addressing much or all of the relevant aspects of the domain. He doesn't just throw his hands up in the air (at least not in public), or castigate his counterparties. Like Smil, I'm not an optimist. I am a realist, however, which means making realistic assessments of the situation and possible future(s). Most of those possible futures don't look so hot, frankly. This is like threading a needle, and the tolerances are low.