2 ms·
But English is a tonal language; that hypothetical problem can't be a source of extreme difficulty for English-speaking learners. (I do have problems with Engl
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
But English is a tonal language; that hypothetical problem can't be a source of extreme difficulty for English-speaking learners.
(I do have problems with English tones interfering with my attempts to speak Chinese, but that's really not the same problem as "My language doesn't use tones, so I don't know how to produce them". I do know how; I just don't have good control over them.)
- yorwba 7y agoEnglish doesn't have falling-rising contours like the Mandarin third tone, so there's at least the difficulty of having to learn a new category of pitch change. I do wonder whether e.g. Mandarin speakers have similar difficulty acquiring the different contours of e.g. Cantonese. Intuitively, I'd expect it to get easier the more different categories one can already distinguish.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoEnglish does have such a contour, in the fairly special case of the three-tone "I don't know" sequence. (On the "know".)