3 ms·
>And there are strong arguments in favor of absolutist versions of freedom of speech. First, American freedom of speech isn't absolutist. There are laws agains
by krapp 7y ago
>And there are strong arguments in favor of absolutist versions of freedom of speech.
First, American freedom of speech isn't absolutist. There are laws against certain kinds of speech in the US, such as fraud, slander, libel, incitement to violence, conspiracy, etc. And many people seem to believe that Americans' right of association is in conflict with freedom of speech, as it allows the owners of private venues to determine what forms of speech can and cannot take place in those venues.
Second, this is not a strong argument in favor unless you happen to be an anti-vaxxer or simply lack empathy.
- godshatter 7y ago> Second, this is not a strong argument in favor unless you happen to be an anti-vaxxer or simply lack empathy. He spoke out against vaccines on Facebook, and suggested using papaya leaves and/or vitamin C instead. You don't have to be an anti-vaxxer or lack empathy to disagree with his being arrested for this.
- krapp 7y ago>He spoke out against vaccines on Facebook, and suggested using papaya leaves and/or vitamin C instead. In other words, he suggested people in the midst of an outbreak of a deadly, contagious but treatable disease avoid that treatment in favor of homeopathic bullshit that will only result in more deaths and further contagion. Believing he should be allowed to do so without consequence shows a complete lack of empathy for his victims.
- godshatter 7y agoSure, I totally disagree with him, but I'd like the bar for freedom of speech to be a bit higher that. He didn't specifically threaten anyone, and he's not dispensing advice in a professional capacity. He's just some guy with a different opinion, on that bastion of obvious truth known as Facebook posts. That opinion might lead someone who reads it to not get vaccinated, which might cause real problems, but just putting his opinion out there shouldn't be cause for arrest. In my, obviously unpopular, opinion.
- krapp 7y ago> He's just some guy with a different opinion, on that bastion of obvious truth known as Facebook posts. Not really, though. I searched his name and found an interview with Stuff magazine[0] which describes him as a "Samoan traditional healer and well known anti-vaxxer." It also describes his social media efforts as being far more active than "just putting his opinion out there" would imply. This isn't some random guy the government decided to harass for "wrongthink", He's an activist trying to undermine and hinder his government's attempt to vaccinate people in the midst of a medical emergency, as part of a greater anti-vaccination movement. [0]https://www.stuff.co.nz/world/south-pacific/117918981/samoa-measles-outbreak-edwin-tamasese-first-antivaxxer-arrested https://www.stuff.co.nz/world/south-pacific/117918981/samoa-...
- the_watcher 7y ago> fraud, slander, libel, incitement to violence, conspiracy, etc. Let's go one by one: * Fraud: not sure what you mean here. Fraudulent speech? Lying isn't a crime. Fraud is a crime that might involve speech, but there are more elements than simply stating an untruth. * Slander/libel: Yes, this is an exception, but it is notably narrow and again has additional required elements. * Incitement to violence: Nope. Incitement to _lawless_ action is simply one of the elements of the sole case in which someone can be prosecuted for _speech alone_ ("directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action.") * Conspiracy: Again, unsure what you mean. Where is the "conspiracy" exception to free speech?
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Lying isn't a crime. Wellllll... In the US, the courts are split over whether untrue speech is protected by the first amendment. And there are some very wide-ranging laws that require "honest dealing" or "honest services" in general at all times.
- the_watcher 7y agoCan you provide citations for this? "Honest dealing" and "honest services" laws all require more than simply "untrue speech", in every case that I've seen.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThe recent college admissions scandal mostly charged parents with wire fraud, if I recall correctly. The fraudulent part of their conduct consisted solely of untrue speech, representing to a school that an SAT score was earned by their child when it wasn't, or representing to the College Board that the person taking the test was their child when it wasn't.[1] [1] There were other methods, but the two I list here seem in my eyes to consist exclusively of untrue speech. There were also fraud charges associated with representing payments as donations to a charity (for tax reasons) when they were meant as quid pro quo payment for services. If the tax fraud was the basis for every fraud charge, I'll admit that this example is invalid.