5 ms·
FTC rules 5-0 that Cambridge Analytica engaged in deceptive practices [pdf]
- mindslight 7y agoThis is what early stage regulatory capture looks like. Now that some token bad actors have been called out, we can go back to ignoring the elephant in the room of the too-big-to-fail surveillance companies keeping databases that would make the staunchest Stasi agent blush.
- munk-a 7y agoIt looks like a pretty nice outcome for CA, no persons involved are being hit with criminal charges, instead they're limited to just constraints on future actions - additionally CA has filed for bankruptcy and there is no initiative I can see in this order that goes after original investors as having conspired on these charges, so they'll lose their investment but that was probably a write off anyways.
- sigstoat 7y ago> no persons involved are being hit with criminal charges can the FTC or whoever else is involved _at_ _this_ _stage_ even file criminal charges against individuals? we see over and over comments of the "omg no criminal charges" variety whenever a government body that can't file criminal charges fails to do so.
- vermontdevil 7y agoI’m sure they can refer to Justice Department to go down that path?
- deadmutex 7y agoIf you're sure, why does your reply end in a question mark?
- justrobert 7y agoYour issue is with a person using spoken English in a text medium. No way to convey intonation in text so people often use a question mark to convey it.
- bcoates 7y agoIt's not an intonation thing, the idiom is "Surely (conditionally true statement)?" and uppost was verbing for some reason
- BubRoss 7y agoI'm with you buddy, people putting question marks at the end of statements is obnoxious.
- tyingq 7y agoThey have a liason department that has that mission: https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/criminal-liaison-unit https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/criminal-liaison-unit
- shaneprrlt 7y agoThey're known for imposing fines that are minuscule relative to the amount of damage whoever they're investigating caused. For most deceptive operations large enough to land on the FTC's radar, whatever fines they might end up paying are considered a speeding ticket and cost of doing business. It's sad, really. They're also known for being massively understaffed relative to the amount of complaints they receive.
- dylan604 7y agoSo what is the difference between CA, corporate banks, etc that are corporations that "shield" the employees from personally facing criminal action, and me running out to file an LLC/SCorp/etc to do illegal activities myself? Is it purely the size of their bank accounts?
- wahern 7y agoIt's the size of an organization and the complexity of the enterprise. Large, sophisticated corporations effectively shield executives from personal criminal liability because decision making is more diffuse--or at least they have an easier time arguing that. If a prosecutor could establish that a Fortune 500 CEO had the same, unmoderated role in criminal activity as the CEO of a one man shell company, then he'd be just as easy to prosecute and undoubtedly would--that'd make the careers of the D.A. and the attorneys working the case. There aren't many (or any?) laws that criminalize scheming, amoral profiteers who effectively (but not literally) promote a culture of lawlessness. Even if you write them they'd be very hard to prosecute--Due Process protections are strong in the US and Anglosphere systems, at least if you have the money and wherewithal. A bigger problem is that executives and board members are financially shielded, often through corporate-bought personal liability insurance. Maybe things would get better if there were laws mandating clawbacks, with independent agents[1] tasked with drafting the contracts and enforcing clawbacks, and perhaps somehow preventing executives from insuring themselves, such as with mandatory right of recourse clauses (i.e. insurer can always recover their payouts from the insured, making them more like guarantors). This aspect of corporate law is really complex though because it touches on so many subject areas. And stuff like this has been tried--it's how we ended up with corporate-bought personal insurance policies, a response to a brief period where executives and board members found themselves financially exposed during the early years of professional shareholder lawsuits. [1] Even though technically this is supposed to be the responsibility of board members. But that's an even thornier problem.
- akira2501 7y ago> even file criminal charges against individuals? Usually it would be recommended to FBI for legal review, and if they find that laws were broken, then referred to the DOJ for prosecution. > we see over and over comments of the "omg no criminal charges" If you committed a crime, whether violent or financial, then you should be prosecuted. It's disheartening to see government lawyers give away the candy store every time just so they can secure a "quick" negotiation and move on with their jobs. Unless people have _real_ disincentives to break the law.. guess what? They're just going to break the law and hide behind their money for as long as we let them. This needs to change or we're going to experience the 1930s again.
- lvs 7y agoI think you misunderstand what the FTC does. The FTC does not have the power to charge individuals under criminal indictments.
- munk-a 7y agoThe FTC has the ability to recommend charges and often will name and shame involved parties - additionally the FTC could extend the liability for these fines to the backers of CA if they chose to and that'd honestly send a ridiculously strong message - investing in something this shady should really break out of the standard liability agreements of a corporation and extend to personal assets. If the investors behind CA were aware of the shady business CA was trying to do (and all signs point strongly to yes in this case) then they conspired. If they conspired they should be prosecuted accordingly and this seems like a good and easy charge to press.
- anigbrowl 7y agoId' be interested in some examples of past recommendations from the FTC that lead to indictments or at least investigations.
- lvs 7y agoThey could potentially refer, but they would at best be referring for further investigation since many of the investigative tools necessary to pursue individual criminal indictments are not available to them. The FTC is limited to administrative powers and can take civil actions -- that's it. As far as going after investors for fines, I've never heard of such an attempt by the FTC against backers of an LLC, and I suspect that would be tied up in courts and legally inviable. It's nice to fantasize about regulators making these kinds of smackdowns, but their real world powers are quite limited by statute and case law.
- shakna 7y ago> instead they're limited to just constraints on future actions Just as a small reminder: CA is officially shutting down. [0] They're also re-emerging as Emerdata. [1] (Same people, same office, different name and registration.) [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/business-43983958 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-43983958 [1] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/05/02/cambridge_analytica_shutdown/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/05/02/cambridge_analytica...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- remotecool 7y agoWhataboutism applies here. The Democrats can get away with murder. Obama did nearly the same thing during his 2008 campaign. Where is the real justice and why do we only care when its politically motivated it helps someone we dislike?
- criley2 7y agoFalse equivalence applies here. Barack Obama did not hire a foreign agency to accept laundered intelligence from a hostile foreign intelligence agency to target American voters for disinformation and propaganda to materially affect an American election. It's not illegal for American companies, complying with American election regulations, to be hired by an American campaign to help with an American election. It's very illegal and fundamentally a Constitutional crisis to involve foreign firms and foreign militaries in your campaign, however. Our founders discussed this in the Federalist Papers and elsewhere, how protecting our elections from foreign influence was of the most important parts of maintaining soverignity (and helps understand precisely what we lose when we legitimize Donald Trumps work with foreign militaries to attack our own country by limply comparing it to non-equal and legal counter examples). It has never happened in our entire history, that a candidate for office would work with foreign firms and hostile militaries to attack our own elections. Well, until 2016. Whataboutism is a perfect description of your tactic: a rhetorical trick to create false equivalence to hide far greater crimes under the guise of "everyone does it"
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into partisan flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- remotecool 7y agoDemocrat have been using CA for years in an attempt to win elections. Why is it only bad when Trump uses them and wins? TDS is alive and well it seems. Obama hired an attorney, most likely affiliated with the Russian government, to investigate trump during the 2016 election. This was known as the steel dossier. It was plastered all over the news and used as the first attempt to impeach trump with 'Russian collussion'. I could easily see this as Obama conspiring with the Democrats to spy on a political rival. No major investigation has materialized. Hillary not just used a gmail account. She ran an entire email server and had classified emails go through it. Many here on HN temporarily got stupid about the technical implications of this and how much of a crime it really is. Not one charge was brought against her. Bidens son, a fuckup and a drug addict, gets a job as an executive in an oil company, and makes at least a million a year. Biden not only fires the prosecutor investigating this company, but brags about it on live TV. This deserves at least an investigation. Tech companies like Google, Facebook, and Twitter actively stifle the free speech of non-liberals and this will directly affect the outcome of our next and future elections. If this were being run by anyone else, there would be protests in the streets. I could go on. Trumps presidency has been littered with attempts to smear his name with alleged crimes that the Democrats are doing themselves. Everyone does do it. But even if the Democrats are caught red handed, the media ignores it and nobody gets punished. There truly is no justice.
- ones_and_zeros 7y agoIn this timeline a ruling like this probably increases their valuation, too bad they filed for bankruptcy.
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoThe way I heard the story, Alexander Nix was a chronic exaggerator who pushed the narrative that CA had a huge impact on Brexit and other elections when it simply wasn't true. He did this in order to gain more sales. They said the Facebook data was deleted by the time of the Trump campaign. My theory is that they are not so different than a typical digital ad agency but they got caught up in a political tornado. I think we should at least be open minded to the possibility they have been scapegoated here.
- wavefunction 7y ago"Don't be so open-minded your brain falls out"
- rsynnott 7y ago> Nix said that his company uses honey traps, bribery stings, and prostitutes, for opposition research VERY NORMAL DIGITAL AD AGENCY THINGS.
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoIt is possible Nix made all that up as a weird form of bragging to close a sale to a sleazy customer. I couldn't find any actual evidence to the contrary. This isn't my theory, it is literally what a CA employee told me in person.
- rsynnott 7y agoIn the immortal words of Mandy Rice-Davies, “well, he would, wouldn’t he”. People quite rarely say “why, yes, my employer does crimes”.
- PixyMisa 7y agoAh, I see you've worked with SEO companies too.
- batterystd 7y agoBut that how will I reconcile the cnn propaganda that drumf is always wrong and democratic party is always right and they lost because drumf cheated and not because democratic party sells out to China?
- pjc50 7y agoThe real question is, which company is doing the unethical data collection and covert advertising today? Ready for the December UK election?
- deepakhj 7y agoCambridge Analytica -> Emerdata https://www.fastcompany.com/90381366/the-mysterious-afterlife-of-cambridge-analytica-and-its-trove-of-data https://www.fastcompany.com/90381366/the-mysterious-afterlif...
- sysyefyct 7y agoIs that the real question? No one cared in the US till a republican won using data collection. It's probably why big tech favors pandering to the Dems, if you don't you get ripped apart.
- newnewpdro 7y agos/company is/companies are/
- m0zg 7y agoI'd be interested in seeing an unanimous FTC ruling on Barack Obama's campaign downloading and mining the entire Facebook social graph in 2012, with Facebook's implicit consent. And unlike the Trump campaign, Obama's did use this data for more than just winning the primary. It went something like this: you downloaded an app on FB and that app would grab not just your data, but also _that of your friends_. FB turned the blind eye. Nary a word from the press, too. https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/facebook-data-scandal-trump-election-obama-2012/ https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/facebook-data-...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sysyefyct 7y agoThe downvotes are because saying anything negative about Democrats or positive about Republicans isn't allowed here.
- makomk 7y agoThe FTC's basis for this ruling against Cambridge Analytica is that they deceived users about what data was being gathered and how it was being used in order to get access. The 2012 Obama campaign didn't. Now that's not to say that they had any sort of consent from the people they were gathering information from - they clearly didn't, because they were scraping information about friends just like CA - or that what they were doing wasn't creepy and morally dubious. It just means that the reasoning in this opinion doesn't apply. In fact, they don't seem to allege that CA committed any kind of violation by scraping the data of US friends of people who used their app, precisely because those users didn't consent. Their argument is that CA breached the FTC Act by making false or misleading representations to get people to give them access to their data, but they can't stretch that to cover scraping of their friends' data because those friends never agreed to anything and CA made no promises to users about their friends.
- m0zg 7y agoBut it kinda did, tho. I really doubt the users understood the full extent of the data they were _actually_ sharing, and particularly that this data included data of all their friends as well.