6 ms·
Instead of saying OTA doesn't count, why don't you just set the requirements as both speed and data cap requirements? So that an OTA solution that has high enou
by cortesoft 7y ago
Instead of saying OTA doesn't count, why don't you just set the requirements as both speed and data cap requirements? So that an OTA solution that has high enough speed and high enough data caps would count.
I don't think encoding a current limitation into law is a good idea. If they can provide a wireless internet that meets the requirements, that is good enough for me.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI’d add a latency maximum too, which would be low enough to disqualify wireless connections. A fiber circuit to each home is the minimum I would accept.
- jakemal 7y agoWhile I agree access to the wealth of information on the internet should be a right, I don't think it's necessary to require every household to have gaming level latency. OTA latency is generally good enough for doing what really matters on the internet.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt really helps with communications, and there’s just no reason not to since a symmetric connection is going to be fiber anyway, might as well beef it up for low marginal cost and make it a little future proof.
- dillonmckay 7y agoI think we can all agree on a maximum of say 300ms, right?
- isostatic 7y agoWhat latency? 100ms is fine for pretty much every internet use there is.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoUsing the internet with connections that have 5ms latency is a far better experience than 100ms, especially with real time communications. Also, everyone should have symmetric connections, none of this 250mbps down and 3mbps up BS.
- EpicEng 7y agoSure, and living in a mansion is a far better experience than living in public housing. We're talking about service as a "right", right?
- mcny 7y agoOn the other end of the spectrum, why does the federal government spend money on the "interstate" highway in Hawaii? Why does every state (even Wyoming) have two senators? I think we should have use common sense here. Fiber deployment is expensive but it is probably worth pulling fiber at least to every post office in these United States.
- wool_gather 7y agoDo you literally mean internet access in the post office building, or are you using that as a metonym for population centers?
- mcny 7y ago> Do you literally mean internet access in the post office building, or are you using that as a metonym for population centers? I didn't even know the word metonym but you said it better than I could have. Yes, I mean population centers. I mean we have to be reasonable. If someone moves to the South Pole and demands we run fiber there, we might have to say no. I don't know where we exactly draw the line though. My understanding is that there is a lot of "dark fiber" criss crossing the country that can be "lit up" so the "long haul" isn't so much of a problem as the "last mile". I could be wrong though. I don't know much about these things.
- Mindless2112 7y agoThe speed of light through optical fiber is slower than the speed of electromagnetic waves through air, so good wireless could be lower latency than good fiber.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoYes, but for whatever reason, no wireless connection is as good as a wired connection today, and as far as I know, wired will still be superior to wireless for a long time.
- cortesoft 7y agoWith 5G, the 'air latency' will be about 8-12ms. That is about the same as a wired connection (from your house to the ISP) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5G https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5G
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThat will be nice, but I’ll believe it when I see it. Tech claims are usually exaggerated, or ignore overhead in the real world.
- partiallypro 7y agoI guess it would depend, I do understand that they could build a 4G tower near everyone that serves well and has no datacaps...but what happens when people clog up the tower? Wireless has a lot of problems landlines (generally) don't have. I guess OTA would be fine, if the telecom could prove that it could handle over a certain amount of traffic without throttling (this is generally why throttling exists.)
- isostatic 7y agoWhat happens when your 1G FTTP is plugged into a 48 port switch with a 10G uplink and you're throttled to 200M?
- nrp 7y agoThe same thing that happens when wired ISPs oversubscribe their infrastructure. Users get less than than theoretical maximum speed. Wireless infrastructure doesn’t inherently have this problem and wired infrastructure doesn’t inherently solve it. The bigger problem with wireless internet access is probably geographical constraints where neighboring sites can have drastically different quality depending on what is between them and the closest tower.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWired ISP over subscription is easy to solve.
- polski-g 7y agoBecause wireless spectrum is a finite resource. We literally can't use more of it than is available.
- cortesoft 7y agoWe are nowhere near the theoretical limits of the wireless bandwidth.