4 ms·
It’s funny you mention the Nordic countries. People always take one piece of the Nordic solution then ignore the other pieces. It’s true that in Stockholm, a pu
by rayiner 7y ago
It’s funny you mention the Nordic countries. People always take one piece of the Nordic solution then ignore the other pieces. It’s true that in Stockholm, a publicly owned entity (Stokab) owns the fiber. But:
1) It receives no public funding.
2) It has few public mandates or price controls. (No, “must offer subsidized service to disenfranchised people” or similar requirements.)
3) It faces no build-out or universal service requirements. It took Stokab almost 20 years to wire the city. They did it based entirely on demand/revenue potential. They deployed first to businesses and areas with the most revenue potential. Stokab didn’t need public funding because it could deploy in a revenue-directed manner. This is illegal in almost every US city. New York flipped out and tried to file a civil rights lawsuit when Verizon couldn’t meet the five year deadline for wiring the city.
4) It charges large up front fees to hook up to the network.
Stokab would be burned to the ground with civil rights lawsuits if it was attempted in New York or San Francisco.
Likewise, Sweden’s approach to wiring rural areas was very market oriented. Unlike the US, it didn’t mandate providers to serve rural areas (cross subsidizing them with revenues from urban areas). It gave rural homeowners a tax credit of about $600 to subsidize laying their own fiber.
- selimthegrim 7y agoWhat ended up happening with Verizon in NY?
- 0xffff2 7y ago$600? Every time I’ve ever seen anyone talk about getting lines run for rural internet, the price starts at tens of thousands even if there is a line nearby already.
- Wheaties466 7y agoyeah I personally know that when I was getting quotes for a fiber run about ~125m the best quote I got was for just under $10k. That was without having to dig up concrete and repair too.
- namibj 7y agoBurial fiber is like 20~40ct/m. Whether you can get a bucket wheel trench excavator through it at speed or have to dig by hand depends on what's in the ground and how hard the ground is, and how long the stretches are. Otherwise, it's like 10~20min to sufficiently properly terminate the fiber at the ends and that. You can likely get around that if you just order pre-terminated fiber at like 1$/plug and just plug it in at the ends instead of splicing. Sure, this will higher losses, but money. Fiber is literally cheaper than copper for >150m or >=10Gbit/s (though direct-attach cables up to 3~5m are even cheaper) if you can get by without field-terminating fibers.
- rasz 7y agoThis is a 'never seen a shovel yuppie' price. You can rent a walk behind trencher at ~$100-200/day or ~$1-2K/month, it will do 50 meters/day of 1 meter deep trench. Need to lay something in a 40 degree hill overgrown with trees? $200/day AirSpade will do 20 meters/day. Want to hire contractor subcontracting 3 layers deep? that will be $10K.
- Wheaties466 7y agoI completely understand that its possible to do it cheaper. The business then has to take the liability of appointing someone to do this.