3 ms·
I guess he's saying that an unminifier tool is effectively no different than a decompiler, and both are basically unreadable without it. That said, I don't kno
by jandrese 7y ago
I guess he's saying that an unminifier tool is effectively no different than a decompiler, and both are basically unreadable without it.
That said, I don't know of any webassembly decompilers, although I guess they must exist by this point. But also historically decompilers have been imperfect as some of the structure of the code is lost in the compilation process and has to be inferred, sometimes incorrectly, by the decompiler. Compare to a minifier where all you lose is the variable names, comments, and possibly helpful whitespace. All of the structure of the code is still there and there are no heuristics necessary to recreate something that resembles the original source.
- pumanoir 7y agoThat is correct, a minified JS will preserve most of the semantics of the original program. And since the original source can come from any language, how would one know which decompiler to use.
- MikeHolman 7y agoYou could already compile programs from other languages to javascript. https://github.com/jashkenas/coffeescript/wiki/List-of-languages-that-compile-to-JS https://github.com/jashkenas/coffeescript/wiki/List-of-langu... Wasm was effectively an extension of asm.js. It makes the experience of compile-to-web better, but it isn't much more opaque than other projects.
- cjbprime 7y agoThere are certainly wasm decompilers -- wasm2c, wasm2js, etc. You also have access to the browser's JS debugger for breakpoints, line by line execution control, dumping wasm's linear memory. I haven't written any productive WebAssembly but I play Capture The Flag competitions, and it's become frequent for a wasm reverse engineering challenge to be thrown in. The tools are good enough to make that tractable, even for non-experts in wasm like me. It helps a little that it's a stack-based rather than register-based VM. Usually more of the intent of code is preserved that way. It's like reversing a JVM class, rather than like reversing a native binary.
- throwaway40324 7y agoWhat are these Capture The Flag competitions? Do you mind posting a link?
- cjbprime 7y agoSure. My favorite explanation's a short video: https://youtu.be/8ev9ZX9J45A https://youtu.be/8ev9ZX9J45A