3 ms·
I think we need to get out of this "capitalist" vs "communist" mindset. There are not just two economic possibilities: "everything is an unregulated market" and
by nicoburns 7y ago
I think we need to get out of this "capitalist" vs "communist" mindset. There are not just two economic possibilities: "everything is an unregulated market" and "everything is top-down planned".
There exist possible future economic systems which use markets where appropriate. Centrally plan where appropriate. And regulate where appropriate.
- mc32 7y agoSure but people seem to have the impression that the “bad things” happen especially in capitalist systems of the west and that other alternate systems like communism would have s different attitude toward the same issues. My experience tells me they had the same attitude but with fewer safeguards and oversight.
- nicoburns 7y agoWell my view is that both capitalism and communism have these problems, but that other alternate systems (which are neither capitalism or communism) could have better solutions. Specifically: - Pure capitalist systems all but rule out strong market regulation. It's not technically incompatible with a market-based system, but in practice people tend to start shouting "but that's not capitalism" as soon as you start proposing regulation as an expected norm as opposed to an unusual exception - Communist systems all but rule out market-based solutions, which is just dysfunctional as it centralises power too much, and makes it difficult to efficiently distribute resources I think it's unhelpful (bordering on obtuse) to assume that people criticising capitalism in 2019 are advocating for communism. Very few people would advocate for communism. What people are calling for is: - A recognition that market failures are not an exception: they are common. And strong regulation is needed to counteract that. - Large wealth equalities distort markets, and that we need limits on the amount of wealth individuals can control.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThat’s a common strategy to defend the status quo and scare people from making Any changes. I think only offering extreme options is especially popular in the US with its two party system. Happens in almost every political discussion.