3 ms·
But isn't it incredibly illegal to claim false certification? Sounds like all those products should be recalled and some companies should be getting steep fines
by mcv 7y ago
But isn't it incredibly illegal to claim false certification? Sounds like all those products should be recalled and some companies should be getting steep fines.
- bradfa 7y agoI don't believe it's a felony or misdemeanor crime, but it could be copyright or trademark infringement if you use a safety approval logo on your product without paying and certifying your product with the agency who owns the logo. A company like UL could sue an infringer for using the UL marks on products which UL has not certified, but I think that's about it. UL enforcement info: https://www.ul.com/news/ul-teams-law-enforcement-brand-defense https://www.ul.com/news/ul-teams-law-enforcement-brand-defen... If you claim your device complies with regulations set forth by government agencies such as the FCC or OSHA when it does not, then I think the criminal or other special courts may get involved as it may no longer be just a civil matter. Although FCC violation investigation usually just involve recalling product and paying a "voluntary" fine (it's voluntary, unless you decide not to volunteer, and then it's no longer voluntary). FCC enforcement info: https://www.fcc.gov/general/enforcement-primer https://www.fcc.gov/general/enforcement-primer
- Nextgrid 7y agoWouldn't it be fraud? At least according to the UK definition of fraud (lying for profit) it would fit the bill.
- bradfa 7y agoI guess it could also be fraud to use something like a UL mark without paying and being certified, which could have criminal consequences. If the vendor is attempting to deceive customers by using the mark, it probably counts as fraud for marks that are well known or for specific purposes or industries.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoSome supplier in China doesn't care about that. The drop shipper or importer certainly doesn't care because they can point the finger at the supplier who claimed the certification. To further muddy things, the supplier may very well be knocking off a compliant design and producing a compliant product that simply isn't officially sanctioned as such.
- koboll 7y agoSounds like we need more liability for the sales platform. Or perhaps, a greater distinction in the law between an actual sales platform (i.e. Craigslist) and a sales platform masquerading as a corporate storefront (Amazon). The latter is designed to trick consumers into believing they have the same level of quality assurance as if they bought from Target or Walmart or any other retail operation that purchases and vets products individually before reselling them.
- aussiegreenie 7y agoYes, lying about safety is illegal but the sellers can just close shop and phoenix into another seller. Personally, I think anyone who purchases ANYTHING important off Amazon is crazy. Getting a fake shirt in one thing but getting fake safety equipment is another. Amazon will die do to people suing it out of existence for selling fake stuff.