3 ms·
How do you know that the rock is not aware of stuff? if you say consciousness is just neurons firing in certain patterns you have also given an answer to the tr
by adrianN 7y ago
How do you know that the rock is not aware of stuff? if you say consciousness is just neurons firing in certain patterns you have also given an answer to the traditional "hard" problem of consciousness, with hundreds of pages of philosophical thought that refutes your answer.
- cygx 7y agoIf you're not a dualist, thoughts necessarily have to be accompanied by some change of state of the material substrate.
- adrianN 7y agoDon't underestimate the complexity of a rock's internal state. There is a unfathomable number of atoms in complex crystal lattices in there. Defects in that lattice alone can encode a ton of information. Then you have a bunch of quantum state for each elementary particle. All of that reacts to external stimuli like temperature, pressure, or the occasional cosmic ray.
- cygx 7y agoThoughts are a process, so if they were supported by a crystal lattice, that lattice would have to go through changes. As to your other point, the ergodicity of the system at the very least places a limit on the timescales over which consciousness may persist. I'm fairly confident in my belief that a rock cannot be conscious in any appreciable way.
- skissane 7y agoYou assume that dualism and materialism are the only options. You ignore other possibilities, such as idealism and neutral monism.
- cygx 7y agoYou're right. The dividing line is whether or not you think the physical and the mental necessarily coincide, which is in principle an orthogonal issue.