3 ms·
An opinion piece by David Brooks. One he's made so many times it's in his Wikipedia entry: > Brooks describes himself as having originally been a liberal befor
by eesmith 7y ago
An opinion piece by David Brooks. One he's made so many times it's in his Wikipedia entry:
> Brooks describes himself as having originally been a liberal before, as he put it, "coming to my senses." He recounts that a turning point in his thinking came while he was still an undergraduate, when he was selected to present the socialist point of view during a televised debate with Nobel laureate free-market economist Milton Friedman.[5] As Brooks describes it, "[It] was essentially me making a point, and he making a two-sentence rebuttal which totally devastated my point. ... That didn't immediately turn me into a conservative, but ..."[48]
I can't help but think of the long number of people who tell stories along the lines "I used to be a ... until ...", eg. "I used to be an atheist until I read the Bible, and now I'm a Christian".
Also, not fact checked, since there is no "Palomar lunar observatory".
And strawmanning, as he says "The best version of socialism" then turns around and says 'That’s not what “democratic socialists” like Bernie Sanders are talking about'.
That's of course because there is no best version of socialism. Socialism is fundamentally a critique of capitalism, with different views on how to improve things.
Why aren't democracy or the free market or capitalism the most compelling secular religions of all time, instead of socialism?
"I quickly noticed that the government officials I was covering were not capable of planning the society they hoped to create." - Sure. And socialism doesn't require planned economies. See democratic socialism, above.
"Places that moved toward socialism — Britain in the 1970s .. " That conviently leaves out the social democracies like what Bernie Sanders talks about.
"places that instituted market reforms, like South Korea and Deng Xiaoping’s China, tended to get richer and prouder ... The greatest environmental degradations are committed by planned systems like the old Soviet Union and communist China."
That's deeply ironic. So, communist China gets the bad parts, and market reform China gets the good parts? Because current market reform China is nowhere near an ecoparadise.
"The freest economies in the world are places like Hong Kong, the U.S., Canada, Ireland, Latvia, Denmark, Mauritius, Malta and Finland"
Note please those which have socialized health care, and which of them have socialists in political power. Eg, The leader of the Danish Folkting is a Social Democrat.