15 ms·
Shouldn’t these devices be UL or CE or TÜV rated so that we know they’ve gone through some kind of basic safety testing? There is so much cheap untested crap t
by mc32 7y ago
Shouldn’t these devices be UL or CE or TÜV rated so that we know they’ve gone through some kind of basic safety testing?
There is so much cheap untested crap that gets sold on these platforms. We should stop it.
- ProAm 7y agoDo you think counterfeit products are certified?
- Fnoord 7y agoCertified potentially unsafe.
- sjg007 7y agoThe counterfeit products just use the logo marks and say they are legit even though they are not certified. It takes a savvy consumer to look them up.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoA lot of the product descriptions just lie about that. I recently wanted to buy some dust masks during the fires here in California. People recommended getting N95 certified masks, but when you go to Amazon and search for "N95" most of the listings will claim to be N95 certified but aren't listed on the government's lists of masks that are actually certified. I even found some masks that claimed to be certified and listed their certification number, but when I went to the NIOSH website the certification number was listed as "revoked". The only legit ones seem to be the 3M masks, and there's no telling if the ones they're selling are actually real.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoThanks for posting this! I've been working around a lot of concrete dust lately, and it didn't occur to me that the N95 certs might be lies. Also didn't know there was a government website I could check against.
- mindslight 7y agoIf you're really working around "a lot" of concrete dust, a 3M #7500 half-face base with a P100 (99.97%) filter eg #2297 will only cost you $30-$40. Much better at not fogging up glasses, too.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoFollowing up on the OP's reference to an official list of N95-certified masks: [0] (see also [1]) [0] https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/topics/respirators/disp_part/n95list1.html https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/topics/respirators/disp_part... [1] https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/respirators/ https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/respirators/ > The only legit ones seem to be the 3M masks, and there's no telling if the ones they're selling are actually real. I think the OP misunderstood [0]. That page is specific to products from 3M, but it also links to the pages for other manufacturers' products.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mcv 7y agoBut isn't it incredibly illegal to claim false certification? Sounds like all those products should be recalled and some companies should be getting steep fines.
- bradfa 7y agoI don't believe it's a felony or misdemeanor crime, but it could be copyright or trademark infringement if you use a safety approval logo on your product without paying and certifying your product with the agency who owns the logo. A company like UL could sue an infringer for using the UL marks on products which UL has not certified, but I think that's about it. UL enforcement info: https://www.ul.com/news/ul-teams-law-enforcement-brand-defense https://www.ul.com/news/ul-teams-law-enforcement-brand-defen... If you claim your device complies with regulations set forth by government agencies such as the FCC or OSHA when it does not, then I think the criminal or other special courts may get involved as it may no longer be just a civil matter. Although FCC violation investigation usually just involve recalling product and paying a "voluntary" fine (it's voluntary, unless you decide not to volunteer, and then it's no longer voluntary). FCC enforcement info: https://www.fcc.gov/general/enforcement-primer https://www.fcc.gov/general/enforcement-primer
- Nextgrid 7y agoWouldn't it be fraud? At least according to the UK definition of fraud (lying for profit) it would fit the bill.
- bradfa 7y agoI guess it could also be fraud to use something like a UL mark without paying and being certified, which could have criminal consequences. If the vendor is attempting to deceive customers by using the mark, it probably counts as fraud for marks that are well known or for specific purposes or industries.
- masonic 7y agoThe same thing happened with fake eclipse glasses before the Great American Eclipse.
- em_at_throwaway 7y agoIn concept, yes. My read of Amazon's argument is it's the buyer's responsibility to look for safety certifications and if that isn't available, the buyer shouldn't buy the product. Relevant context: there were no UL certifications for "laptop battery wired to a gyropscope and wheels" in 2016 when the hoverboard craze happened. So the devices were not UL certified but that didn't concern people buying them. Source: UL first hoverboard certified May 2016 https://www.ul.com/hoverboards https://www.ul.com/hoverboards
- ac29 7y agoI dont think its an undue burden to require retailers to verify things like safety certifications. Yes, it might make it impractical to have a company sell billions of different products, but I'd argue thats a good thing. You might say "well, sellers will just counterfeit the certifications", but the fact of the matter is courts tend to look at actions, intentions, and motivations, they dont interpret laws like computers interpret code. The fact that Amazon co-mingles inventory and seemingly has near-zero interest in getting involved in their own supply chain means there is a lot of low hanging fruit that is being ignored in the interest of profits. Changing the law would a step in the right direction, even if imperfect.
- syshum 7y ago>>The fact that Amazon co-mingles inventory That is the biggest problem right there, and should be what shifts the legal liability from the seller to the platform If they want to co-mingle inventory then they should assume the risk and have processes to ensure that the co-mingled inventory is actually the same product not counterfeit
- chopin 7y agoCE is a self-certification (I don't know about UL). For this situation CE is worthless as anyone could put up a sticker.
- mrspuratic 7y agoThey even give you the logo for free: https://ec.europa.eu/growth/single-market/ce-marking_en https://ec.europa.eu/growth/single-market/ce-marking_en (which even legit products manage to get wrong, if you can't reproduce two overlapping circles...)
- sp332 7y agoSome of those logos you see are not CE logos, they are "China Export" logos. The China Export logo is intentionally a direct ripoff of the real CE logo so they are difficult to tell apart. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=china+export+vs+CE&ia=images&iax=images https://duckduckgo.com/?q=china+export+vs+CE&ia=images&iax=i...
- mc32 7y agoThat would seem like a trademark violation as they are clearly trying to make it look like the CE mark in order to fool consumers into believing the product is certified...
- sp332 7y agoThey're working on it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CE_marking#China_Export https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CE_marking#China_Export
- pjc50 7y agoCE certification is self-assessment. Usually there will be testing, but it can be hard to figure what is required and what has been done. Then there's simple fakes and the "China Export" mark.
- Gwypaas 7y agoThat is not really true, "CE marking involves self-certification only in case of minimal risks products. In most cases a notified body must be involved. In these cases the CE mark is followed by the registration number of the Notified body involved in conformity assessment." [0] Also, if you import CE marked products into the EU you as the importer are responsible for the conformity, which is what Amazon tries to dodge here. "Importers of products have to verify that the manufacturer outside the EU has undertaken the necessary steps and that the documentation is available upon request. Importers should also make sure that contact with the manufacturer can always be established. Distributors must be able to demonstrate to national authorities that they have acted with due care and they must have affirmation from the manufacturer or importer that the necessary measures have been taken. If importers or distributors market the products under their own name, they take over the manufacturer's responsibilities. In this case they must have sufficient information on the design and production of the product, as they will be assuming the legal responsibility when they affix the CE marking." [0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CE_marking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CE_marking
- mcv 7y agoThis is even worse with Chinese webshops, where products have fake CE markings. When you order from a Chinese webshop, who is really the importer? The buyer or the shop? The shop would probably claim it's the buyer, but buyers tend to be ordinary consumers who have no idea and no means to verify any of this.
- Gwypaas 7y agoYes, that's very true sadly, it hasn't really caught up to consumers doing international shopping over regulatory borders. My interpretation would be if the shop does not have a European presence you are the importer. Though, I guess if the problem with non-conforming products would become big enough a more extensive declaration of conformity would be needed and actually checked going through customs. For us in Sweden Aliexpress and similar basically died when the postal service started enforcing the customs checks in regards to value and VAT with a fee of $8 plus the VAT per package.