11 ms·
Wow: > 1. Much work in AI has the ``look ma, no hands'' disease. Someone programs a computer to do something no computer has done before and writes a paper poi
by bo1024 7y ago
Wow:
> 1. Much work in AI has the ``look ma, no hands'' disease. Someone programs a computer to do something no computer has done before and writes a paper pointing out that the computer did it. The paper is not directed to the identification and study of intellectual mechanisms and often contains no coherent account of how the program works at all.
(It seems this was written in about 1973, published online in 1993. I infer this because the article being reviewed appeared in 1973, and this one speaks of 1978 as being in the future).
- blt 7y agoThat paragraph could have easily been written in 2019 - probably not surprisingly for McCarthy.
- blt 7y agoAlso: > It would be a great relief to the rest of the workers in AI if the inventors of new general formalisms would express their hopes in a more guarded form than has sometimes been the case.