11 ms·
This by far not a popular opinion, but some jobs aren’t worth $15 an hour. We shouldn’t force social policy on private corporations. Sure she needs more than $9
by scarface74 7y ago
This by far not a popular opinion, but some jobs aren’t worth $15 an hour. We shouldn’t force social policy on private corporations. Sure she needs more than $9.15/hour to live as an adult and pay for insurance but a teenager staying at home doesn’t.
I am strong believer in a social safety net but I think that should be the role of government. She shouldn’t have to depend on private corporations for insurance, that should be the taken care of by government like it is in every other first world country.
We already have a program where the government (instead of corporate America) recognizes that the monetary needs of an adult is different from that of a teenager staying at home - the Earned Income Tax Credit. We as a country should both make that more generous and easier to be distributed through out the year. Historically, the EITC was supported by both Democratic and Republican administrations.
It shouldn’t take her two hours to get to work, we need better public transportation. Heck barring that I wouldn’t be opposed to subsidizing private transportation solutions like working with Uber and Lyft if it’s cheaper long term.
- URSpider94 7y agoHere's a counter-argument: if people are taking jobs that don't cover their cost of living, and the government is having to step in to subsidize them, then that's effectively a subsidy from the government to the company's bottom line. In general, we Americans believe in the free market, but we also believe that we need limits on what people can legally contract for. For example, we don't let people sell organs. We don't let people sell themselves into slavery. We don't let people put their pre-teen children to work. And we do indeed have a minimum wage. Do you feel like we should abolish the minimum wage altogether, or just that it shouldn't be $15/hour. If so, why?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoHence a universal basic income.
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s not the role of every job to provide a livable income. How many people on HN wouldn’t have a job at all if their company wasn’t subsidized by VCs? There was an article posted here a few months ago that the average 7/11 owner makes $35K a year and that’s with them putting in 60+ hour weeks. Most small business owners aren’t getting rich. Actually, I wouldn’t be completely opposed to abolishing the minimum wage and having a universal basic income.
- taurath 7y ago> It’s not the role of every job to provide a livable income. It’s the role of the economy for someone to get a livable income if that’s what they’re seeking. If it’s not working then it needs a nudge.
- throw_away_456 7y agoSure, but there are ways to do this that aren't forcing every single job in said economy to provide that type of income.
- Consultant32452 7y agoWhat standard of living do you consider "livable" and what percentage of the 7.7 Billion people on the planet actually live at that standard? The "living wage" thing is a marketing weasel phrase. It's intentionally non-specific and encourages the listener to fill in their own idea of what kind of lifestyle a "living wage" entails. I would encourage everyone to ignore "living wage" marketing weasel-speak and only listen to concrete, specific goals.
- taurath 7y agoTry at the very minimum matching to inflation, and adjusting the current wage to what it would be if it were. Then all you have to decide is whether the minimum wage should’ve been a thing in the first place.
- scarface74 7y agoThe “living wage” would be different for someone with no dependents and no health problems than someone who has health problems and/or kids.
- Consultant32452 7y agoWhen I read "living wage" I parse it very literally. It sounds like something close to "capable of purchasing just enough food calories for one person to live." It certainly would not afford you luxuries like having children. I'm sure that's not what most people are intending to communicate, but I think that's a good starting point to demonstrate how meaningless the phrase "living wage" really is.
- henryfjordan 7y ago> This by far not a popular opinion, but some jobs aren’t worth $15 an hour. We shouldn’t force social policy on private corporations. Some jobs aren't worth doing, thats for sure. We decided that if a job isn't worth paying someone $15 an hour to do, it's not worth someone doing. The market can figure that out. We're forcing the policy on the worker as much as the corporation, they cannot sell their labor for less than $15 an hour either. We, as society, are saying "if the market says you aren't worth >$15/hour go to school until you are" as thats the best use of everyone's time. Arguing that teenagers deserve less protections against exploitation of their labor is arguing we should go back to pre-industrial revolution policies. I'm also not sure what your point about the EITC is, it gives different amounts of tax credits to adults depending on if they have kids or not recognizing that parenting costs money. You have to be aged 25-65 to claim it if you don't have kids yourself, so teenagers who work do not benefit from it directly. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit
- scarface74 7y agoI know. I’m saying it should be more generous and easier to receive throughout the year.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- baroffoos 7y agoI think this is probably correct but it seems entirely incompatible with modern American society. As an outsider it seems like the way Americans think is "If you don't earn enough its because you didn't work hard enough" And any of your suggestions go against the idea of personal responsibility that is held so strongly.
- kiba 7y agoCheap and quality public housing along with good transportation options will go a long way in reducing poverty.
- tyri_kai_psomi 7y agoUnfortunately, it is either cheap or quality. And news flash, as someone who just recently built a new home, even the "expensive" stuff is hardly "quality" these days. We are paying more for homes with cheaper, younger, less treated wood that rots and warps faster (partially thanks to over-regulation). Majority of what is being thrown up in my city are 450-700k+ McMansions that are "stick built" and will almost assuredly have a host of problems in the near term. Quality is just so rare these days. Everything is built to be replaced in 5-10 years. American homes are a sham. My grandmother's home back in Greece is 180 years old at this point and I fully expect it to outlast my current home.
- liveoneggs 7y ago"minimum wage jobs are for teenagers" is a very popular right wing opinion
- scarface74 7y agoMinimum wage jobs should be an entry level job or for people who are not trying to support themselves. We should have job training and the temporary subsidies necessary so that adults aren’t trying to support a family flipping burgers. But life happens, and that’s where the social safety net comes in. I consider myself a bleeding heart capitalist. It’s a company’s responsible to make money. It should be the government’s responsibility to implement social policy and guard against allowing companies to introduce negative externalities.
- formercoder 7y agoThis is a capex vs opex question. Raise minimum wage enough and firms cross the border to investing in capex such that they replace employees.
- taurath 7y agoIf they’re on the fence already, then they should be doing it. A few hundred dollars a day means next to nothing to McDonald’s, and everything to the workers. Don’t hold the threat of automation over them, if it’s gonna happen rip the bandaid off.
- scarface74 7y agoA few hundred a day means a lot to the franchise owner. It really means a lot to the mom and pop pizzeria down the street or the owner of the convenience store.
- taurath 7y agoAnd the plantation owner. Cheap labor is not a right.
- scarface74 7y agoI’ve asked this before, how much “labor” could the average money losing, VC backed, startup afford?
- formercoder 7y agoIt’s not a matter of a few hundred dollars a day. It’s a matter of whether the decision to replace workers is NPV positive. It’s clearly only so up until the point they are at now with the kiosks.
- asdff 7y agoI think what you are arguing for is we raise minimum wage for adults to a living wage but keep it low for minors claimed as dependents. We should force social policy on private corporations when they are being deliberately exploitative.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd the only reason that people who are working for money losing startups aren’t being “exploited” is because of the access to venture capital. And VCs get a lot of money from public pensions. If low margin businesses don’t “deserve” to be in business, neither do companies losing billions a year.