6 ms·
Deprecating the GitHub Developer Program
- flockonus 7y agoMicrosoft move
- seph-reed 7y agoI jumped ship the moment they bought it. Took almost no time and I really like GitLab.
- nickstinemates 7y agoGiven the ongoing GitHub / ICE controversy which is ever prevalent on Twitter.. I have to wonder. Is there a viable alternative for open source projects with enough of a network? I see people who are very outspoken on the subject that are maintainers of projects on GitHub. Seems rather hypocritical, but maybe there isn't a better option.
- greggyb 7y agoSourcehut: https://sr.ht https://sr.ht Savannah: https://savannah.nongnu.org/ https://savannah.nongnu.org/ GitLab: https://www.gitlab.com https://www.gitlab.com BitBucket: https://www.bitbucket.org https://www.bitbucket.org SourceForge: https://www.sourceforge.net https://www.sourceforge.net If you don't want to be on GitHub, you don't have to be. If you want to avoid a transitive dependency on GitHub, that might be difficult. If you're looking for self-hosting options: Gogs: https://gogs.io/ https://gogs.io/ Gitea: https://gitea.io/ https://gitea.io/ Also, Sourcehut, Savannah, and GitLab from the service offerings can be self-hosted. These are literally off the top of my head, and based primarily on osmosis from browsing HN. I am sure there are many more.
- wongarsu 7y agoBitbucket can be self-hosted too. It's not open source, but the licence fees for self-hosted installs are very reasonable.
- greggyb 7y agoThanks for letting me know. As I said, most of my knowledge of these is just osmosis from comments here. I've used TFS, Visual Studio Online / Azure DevOps, GitHub, GitLab, and SourceHut. My knowledge of the others is purely from people like you. I appreciate it.
- MisterOctober 7y agoSourcehut is one I especially enjoy using, and I really admire the grit + dedication of its developer[s]-- as I mentioned in a related thread a few weeks ago, I intend to migrate my personal projects to Sourcehut.
- xwowsersx 7y agoSo developers will no longer be able to create integrations?
- fhennig 7y agoThey even say that it has served many people very well, why shut it down then? The only reason I can think of is that microsoft wants to provide these features themselves, maybe as a payed option?
- reggieband 7y agoIt could either be competing products or a wish to re-work the policy terms to allow them to carve out some enterprise-contract type flexibility. My experience with Microsoft is that they are consummate enterprise account managers. They hold the hands of enterprise buyers and their sales teams seems to love to have special enterprise features/integrations. My prediction is we will see a newly defined developer program with consumer tiers which will be the tip of an iceberg of enterprise-ready configuration below the surface.
- slimsag 7y agoGitHub appears to be slowly but surely ensuring anyone who extends their ecosystem is either acquired by GitHub or extinguished -- something I am pretty sure everyone who works in the space has known for a long time. It is no coincidence that many of the companies that have used this developer program: Pull Panda, Dependabot and others like Semmle, Spectrum, etc. have been acquired by them. It starts looking a lot like going in the trajectory of an Apple App Store-esque developer platform in terms of lockdown to me. I know GitLab isn't perfect, but I truly appreciate their openness[1] and willingness to partner with others in this space that are trying to improve developer tooling. If we want better developer tools, we need open platforms for those tools to exist. [1] https://about.gitlab.com/partners/integrate/ https://about.gitlab.com/partners/integrate/ Disclaimer: I work in the space (@ Sourcegraph) but the words/thoughts here are my own, I'm not a corporate shill (I hope) :)
- saagarjha 7y agoLove Sourcegraph, by the way. Can’t say how many times I’ve used it instead of GitHub’s anemic search.
- rmccue 7y ago> It starts looking a lot like going in the trajectory of an Apple App Store-esque developer platform in terms of lockdown to me. Worse than that, it looks like Twitter's pattern of acquiring successful businesses using their API, before significantly locking down access.
- ralph84 7y agoHow is https://about.gitlab.com/partners/integrate/ https://about.gitlab.com/partners/integrate/ materially different from https://developer.github.com/marketplace/ https://developer.github.com/marketplace/ ? Not trolling, just curious why you think one is open and one is not when they both provide ways to get a stamp of approval when you write apps to a public API.
- notatoad 7y agois the second link not the thing they just announced the shutdown of? Unless i'm missing something, the big material differnce between gitlab's developer program and github's developer program is that gitlab's version isn't deprecated.
- gregoryl 7y agoSeems rather abrupt, and poorly written as far as output from Github goes. Anyone have inside gossip on whats going on? Smacks of some sort of internal dispute or a security/liability issue?
- samfriedman 7y agoThis is exactly why I prefer GitLab's "radical transparency" approach, for all its warts.
- giancarlostoro 7y ago> GitHub Developer Program will no longer be accepting new applicants in preparation for new programs at GitHub. Sounds like there will be different tiers. Maybe to generate revenue through those tiers? Or am I crazy and reading too much into it.
- timdorr 7y agoFor those worrying, this doesn't mean they're shutting down their API or locking it down. This was their partnership program for companies building on their API: https://web.archive.org/web/20190928071306/https://developer.github.com/program/ https://web.archive.org/web/20190928071306/https://developer...
- shankun 7y agoHi all, this is Shanku Niyogi. I run the Product team at GitHub. I sincerely apologize for this post. We screwed up. This post was made in error, and we are retracting it. We are always looking to improve our programs for developers, and are working on improvements. But this is not the way to make changes. And it is NOT a goal to end our program. Sorry for the confusion.
- bjelkeman-again 7y agoHow could this happen?
- nodelessness 7y agoWe are better than this.
- tomswartz07 7y agoIt's 2019, for pete's sake and other empty management-type neologisms!
- tyingq 7y agoIf possible, it might be helpful to share a little detail on how it happened. You can imagine that it did happens signals at the very least that someone with power/influence got this post out there in the first place.
- shankun 7y agoThat is a very reasonable ask. I'll be doing a post-mortem, and talking to all the individuals involved - and will do a followup post on it on the same blog. Please stay tuned. And, again, our sincere apologies.
- outnmbout 7y agoThey've agreed to deprecate the program but once the post was out and got terrible feedback, they realized that deprecating a developer program is not the best idea for something like GitHub, let alone announcing it as such. So instead of admitting they've made a mistake in deprecating the program, they're blaming the messenger and pretending it never happened. They went as far as getting the archive.org pages blacklisted/hidden apparently, which shows somewhat clearly the mindset involved.
- sdan 7y agoI use the Developer Program to create Personal Access Token pretty frequently, what will happen to that?
- maxilevi 7y agoThe post was deleted, here is a mirror: https://web.archive.org/web/20191205225751/https://developer.github.com/changes/2019-12-05-gdp-deprecation/ https://web.archive.org/web/20191205225751/https://developer...
- floatingatoll 7y agoThe post was declared false and retracted in an HN comment above.
- justinclift 7y ago"Hrm. The Wayback Machine has not archived that URL."
- Lord_Nightmare 7y agoThe calendar view on archive.org shows the page was archived 6 times while active, but all of those copies seem to have been manually deleted from archive.org (or perhaps hidden/blacked out?), or something else weird is going on.
- atesti 7y agohttp://archive.is/1higF http://archive.is/1higF
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]