3 ms·
> Unwin described four “great patterns of human culture” and degrees of flourishing measured in terms of architecture, art, engineering, literature, agriculture
by aazaa 7y ago
> Unwin described four “great patterns of human culture” and degrees of flourishing measured in terms of architecture, art, engineering, literature, agriculture, and so forth. ...
The article doesn't define the word "flourish," despite using it 11 times. Given the importance of this concept to the conclusions, it seems only fair to have some working definition, and ideally one that uses some objective, quantitative measure of "flourish" as applied to a culture.
That said, the original work was written at a time (1930s) at which non-western cultures were neither well understood nor respected. Without some quantitative grounding it's going to be hard to shake the notion that all the author is doing is re-iterating contemporary western values and ideals.
Oddly, the article doesn't mention anything about gender-specific expectations. The notion of pre-marital continence mainly applied to women, AFAICT. Men enjoyed much greater latitude and have for a very long time, despite what the church and morality observers may preach.
Edit: Why is this article flagged?
- FisDugthop 7y agoThe article is flagged because the author is an anti-intellectual Bible-thumper, and we don't need such silliness.
- crgwbr 7y agoDisagreeing with an article isn’t grounds for flagging it.
- hprotagonist 7y agoI don't know anything one way or another about the author, but his website lists him having a phd in biophysics from an actual, respectable research university (university of Guelph), so i'm not real sure how "anti-intellectual" pertains per se. I'm pretty sure i don't think he's right, but that's not at all the same thing.