3 ms·
The findings are a bit suspect IMHO. > The swiftness with which rational thinking declined after the 1970’s is astounding. In its place arose post-modernism, c
by jandrese 7y ago
The findings are a bit suspect IMHO.
> The swiftness with which rational thinking declined after the 1970’s is astounding. In its place arose post-modernism, characterized by “scepticism, subjectivism, or relativism” and “a general suspicion of reason”.[9] But it gets worse … post-modernism is giving way to “post truth”. In direct contrast to rational thinking, a post-truth culture abandons “shared objective standards for truth” and instead, stands on appeals to feelings and emotions, and what one wants to believe.[10] People can now “identify” themselves as something which flat-out contradicts science and rational thinking and, in many cases, receive the full support and backing of governments and educational systems. Not only do people feel they have a right to believe what they want, but any challenge to that belief, even if supported by truth and logic, is unacceptable and offensive.
While I'm concerned about anti-intellectualism in this country I don't think it is worse than it was in the 1970s. The idea that "rational thinking" is in decline requires more evidence than the author provides. In particular his assertion that recognizing non-binary gender as a sign of anti-intellectualism doesn't seem to be supported by any evidence. What he is presenting as evidence of anti-intellectualism is just society moving beyond the overly simplistic model of humanity from 1932.
> he suggests that when sexual energy is restrained through celibacy or monogamy, it is diverted into more productive social energy.
I'm skeptical.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoRegarding your first objection, I can't prove it. I have nothing but my own perception, but it certainly seems to me that today we are "post truth" in a way that we weren't in the 1980s. (I was in high school in the 1970s, so maybe I wasn't in the best place to judge that decade.) Now, it easily could be that, being more mature now, I find it easier to see the irrationality of peoples' positions today. That's quite possible. But it seems to me that the world - or at least the public discourse - is much less rational today than it was 30 years ago.
- jandrese 7y agoI don't think it's that people are less rational, just that irrational people have more of a platform these days. They were always around, but they didn't get as much airtime in the 1970s. The democratization of publishing has allowed them to finally have a voice, repugnant as that voice may be.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 7y agoLet me put it this way: In the 1980s, religion, the stereotypical implementation of irrationality, was still a lot more prevalent and influential in society than it is now. But, as religious people do, he makes everything into its opposite: Oppressing people's identity and desires is (sexual) morality, believing unfounded superstitions is rationality, and large parts of society being culturally oppressed is a sign of cultural flourishing.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoYes, you might be doing just a bit of stereotyping there...
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 7y agoThe author of that article obviously fits that stereotype more than perfectly, and the general pattern is definitely a thing, functionally atheistic people who claim to be Christians and anything in between notwithstanding. So ... what is your point?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThat, for all your viewing of religious people as being irrational, you are not actually thinking here. You're looking at this as coming from "them", and therefore you don't have to think or consider it. You just reject it as coming from "them", and "they" have nothing worthwhile to say. Which, ironically, fits the argument of the article.