7 ms·
Serious question: what else those websites are supposed to do (that AMP does not provide) with all those megabytes of scripts? Newspapers display a text and an
by mrtksn 7y ago
Serious question: what else those websites are supposed to do (that AMP does not provide) with all those megabytes of scripts?
Newspapers display a text and an image and very rarely an interactive content(Election day maps and charts, mostly).
Is there a reason FROM USERS PERSPECTIVE to have different website codebase for each publisher?
For years the Web community kept creating new JavaScript libraries every day and all these web libraries were about providing a different way to do the same thing. No one ever created anything for the users, in fact, AMP is the first web technology that improves the user experience. It's loading fast and not too much stuff happens to display a text and an image.
Web people are mad at Google and I think they should be but all this happens because the web publishers refuse to compete on User Experience. They all optimize for the clickbitiest title or controversial topic and Google came and steamrolled their publishing tech.
I can't really blame Google for this one, you can check it out - I am critical of Google but I am more critical of the news business or the web tech community that optimized for very bad KPI that destroyed democracy, made web unpleasant and are now crying because of someone demolished their low-quality business.
From USERS PERSPECTIVE, AMP is a godsend. You can quickly view and skim low-quality content. The alternative is slowly viewing and skimming low-quality content.
It seems like the web technologists are unaware that they are dealing with real human beings, optimizing blindly for page views and CPMs.
AMP is Youtube for written content. A strealined conent delivery platform prioritizing UX that the publishers failed to create themselves all these years.
- buboard 7y agofrom USERS PERSPECTIVE, amp is meh. yes it's faster, does it really matter if you re getting an article in 1 second when you -obviously- plan to spend 2 minutes reading it? i dont know anyone who thinks so, perhaps your USERS do > A strealined conent delivery platform prioritizing UX that the publishers failed to create what you re implying is, Google failed to improve their algorithms to bypass obvious SEOs, so they are forcing everyone to use a dumbed down platform that is harder to SEO - for now!
- mrtksn 7y agoActually, it's a pretty well-known fact that users leave websites if they are not loading fast. People don't go with reading plans to websites, the titles are optimized to bring you there and you don't know what's in the article. More often than not, the text on the website is not what the title made you believe it is. You can't plan ahead, you want to quickly find out what is this all about. The article themselves are usually garbage optimized for SEO, long paragraphs of sentences that say the same thing but with different keywords. If that's not enough, they try to sway attention with ads and popups. Even if you had a plan about reading an article, the publisher's plan about you is different(tip: it's not about letting you read in peace). The Web is horrible, it's even more horrible on mobile. AMP is an improvement.
- buboard 7y ago> users leave websites if they are not loading fast then google is doing a bad job of presenting these sites to users, since obviously these sites should lose their rank, since users leave them. Google surely thinks bounce rates are important, no? > The article themselves are usually garbage optimized for SEO, long paragraphs of sentences and how is AMP fixing this? and who is responsible for SEO having these incentives? SEO literally means they optimize for what google wants
- mrtksn 7y agoThey do lose ranks[0]. AMP is fixing this because you can take a peek into the content almost instantaneously so you can just see what is this all about and leave. https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2018/07/search-ads-speed https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2018/07/search-ads...
- buboard 7y agoi don't see why any webmaster would want users who "peek instantaneously and leave". what a waste of an http request
- 7y ago
- bassman9000 7y agoAMP is Youtube for written content. A strealined conent delivery platform prioritizing UX that the publishers failed to create themselves all these years. Do you pay for youtube? Because the vanilla youtube experience is an ad-ridden UX nightmare. If AMP is YouTube, AMP sucks.
- mrtksn 7y agoI use adblocking on Safari(mobile and desktop), so the web experience for me is very good. On the iPhone App, the ads are annoying but I do understand that this is how the content is paid for, so I am O.K. with it. The main difference is that with many websites things jump around when on Youtube the design is clearly defined. There's no cognitive load in trying to find the content between those "subscribe" popups and menus etc. They clearly designed their experience with the understanding that you are there to watch a video. Actually, YouTube's website is so good that the first thing that appears on the page is the video and it starts playing when the rest of the page(like, subscribe buttons suggested videos etc.) is still loading and not rendered. Most websites on the other hand act as if the content was the bite to lure you there and try to make you subscribe/create an account/ allow notifications/show you ads and it's their failure if you actually happen to consume the content that was promised to you from the link you clicked. Completely different experiences.
- bassman9000 7y agoWhat's the point of praising youtube's UX if you're blocking part of it?
- mrtksn 7y agoI'm blocking ads on all the websites, my content blocker is not youtube-only. Still, other websites suck and Youtube is great because UX is not just about ads.
- jammygit 7y agoI’m just annoyed at my links being hijacked. When I click a link, my intention is to visit someone’s page, not to view it through some sort of creepy iframe. When I go to share a link, why is it a google link instead of the newspaper? Why do I have to spend a minute or two hunting for the real one in the ugly ui?
- mrtksn 7y agoI agree with this, I don’t want to share AMP links because it feels wrong for some reason. Still, on the right top corner there’s a share button that would give you the link to the original source.
- gregable 7y agoPublishers who implement Signed Exchanges get AMP links directly to their site with no iframe viewer on browsers that support the technology: https://amp.dev/documentation/guides-and-tutorials/optimize-and-measure/signed-exchange/ https://amp.dev/documentation/guides-and-tutorials/optimize-... https://github.com/WICG/webpackage/blob/master/explainer.md https://github.com/WICG/webpackage/blob/master/explainer.md
- dmitriid 7y agoHello, gregablr, who works on AMP and doesn't disclose it. You mean: - signed exchanges created an pushed by Google and Google only to solve a problem that didn't exist before AMP - "implemented by some browsers" as in "implemented only in Goigle Chrome" even before there was any consensus or standards work as yet another avenue of creating Google-onlu web.
- dang 7y agoPersonal attacks will get you banned here, so please don't post like this. We've asked you more than once, including https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19811041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19811041. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: between the parent comment and these, you were outright harassing another user: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21716790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21716790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21716648 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21716648 And you did it here too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21716607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21716607 This is bannable behavior on HN. I'm not going to ban you because not only have you posted good comments to HN recently, one of them was an Aleksander Blok translation. That's first rate. But please don't do anything like the above in the future. It's important for HN that people be able to discuss their work, or their employers, without being harangued. Should they disclose it? Sure, in principle and when appropriate, but that doesn't mean every comment has to include it like boilerplate. The range of appropriateness has some elasticity. Neither gregable nor joshuamorton was out of line (anyone can just check their profiles). Your attacks on them were out of line though. Using people's employment information to attack them just disincentivizes them to participate in threads that they probably know a lot about, since most of us are experts in what we work on. That's a really bad tradeoff for HN, so users need to pull their punches. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20work%20harangue&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- Sohcahtoa82 7y ago> From USERS PERSPECTIVE, AMP is a godsend. This right here. The first time I found myself on an AMP page, I thought "Holy crap, this page is fast and responsive!" It was a couple months later I started seeing hate for AMP on HN and was kind of surprised. I understand the dislike of Google basically taking over, but I feel like Google is telling publishers "Since you guys can't figure out how to make fast web pages, we're gonna basically do it for you". > AMP is Youtube for written content. A few commenters have taking issue with this, but I interpreted it to mean early YouTube. Before YouTube became a thing, sharing videos online was difficult for a non-technical person. Just like YouTube made it easy to share videos, AMP has made it easy to make responsive pages. Though a key difference is that it isn't hard to make responsive mobile web pages. Site owners have just decided that tracking, metrics, and advertising is more important than UX.
- saagarjha 7y ago> The alternative is slowly viewing and skimming low-quality content. No, the alternative is quickly skimming low-quality content with an adblocker and reader mode.